Schizophrenia in ‘A Beautiful Mind’ Film Essay (Movie Review)
Introduction.
Psychologists have often debated the pedagogical discourse of mental illness depicted in films. The question that often arises is if the representation of the symptoms of the disorder and medical treatment shown in films is historically correct. This essay analyses A Beautiful Mind (2001), a film about mental disorder, directed by Ron Howard. The film shows a renowned mathematician’s struggle with schizophrenia (Howard, 2001). A Beautiful Mind is a biographical film on the life of Professor John Nash and his tryst with paranoid schizophrenia.
The main symptom of a schizophrenic patient depicted in the film is the patient’s inability to distinguish between the real world and the subconscious pattern created within the imaginations of his mind. Nash had created vivid delusions in the form of the “prodigal roommate” and his job as a CIA code-breaker. Therefore, the film shows a schizophrenic patient’s inability to distinguish between reality and hallucination. It shows auditory symptoms common among schizophrenic patients coupled with visual delusions.
Nash has mercurial temperament as his emotions oscillate from absolute antipathy to overwhelming joy. Stress is shown as the main reason that triggers the delusional symptoms in schizophrenic patients. Nash shows symptoms of disorganized speech disorder common among schizophrenic patients. When the illness reached an acute stage, Nash showed symptoms of social withdrawal and mood disturbances.
Schizophrenia is a mental disorder that impairs the activities of the brain, damaging various rational functions (Andreasen, 2000). Schizophrenia is a Greek word meaning the split mind, where ‘split’ implies the dissociation with emotion and thought (Andreasen, 2000). The symptoms of schizophrenia can be divided into two types –positive and negative (Andreasen, 2000). The positive symptoms are the abnormalities in the behavior of the patient, i.e. delusions and hallucinations.
The negative symptoms are mood swings and social withdrawal (Andreasen, 2000). In the case of paranoid schizophrenia, the delusion of grandeur is a common symptom where the patient starts believing in something larger than life. Patients suffering from paranoid schizophrenia are often observed to suffer from delusions with a complex storyline, on the persecution of the wrongdoer. The symptoms of paranoid schizophrenia shown in the movie are correct. The instances of auditory hallucinations, complex delusions, social withdrawal, and stress as a trigger of illusions are the symptoms of the disorder.
The creation of imaginary friends, the complex delusion about the undercover activities, and the inability to distinguish between real and unreal, are beautifully depicted in the film. In the film, John Nash believed that the CIA had recruited him to decipher coded messages during the cold war (Howard, 2001). Clearly, Nash believed that he was the Good Samaritan, working for a greater good. As his delusions advanced, his paranoia and distrust intensified. This is typical behavior of a patient suffering from paranoid schizophrenia. The film has, not only accurately depicted the symptoms and problems of a schizophrenic patient, but has also shown how it can be controlled.
No doubt, the life of a schizophrenic patient will be difficult, as he can no longer think the way a normal human being does, but the film provides hope. The film shows that medication is a short-term method of hallucinations. A better solution is to learn to distrust the irrational. I believe, the film has successfully depicted paranoid schizophrenia and will motivate patients ailing with the disease to cope with the stress of the disorder.
Andreasen, N. C. (2000). Schizophrenia: the fundamental questions. Brain Research Reviews, 31(2), 106-112.
Howard, R. (Director). (2001). A Beautiful Mind [Motion picture on DVD]. USA: Universal Pictures.
- Chicago (A-D)
- Chicago (N-B)
IvyPanda. (2020, August 19). Schizophrenia in 'A Beautiful Mind' Film. https://ivypanda.com/essays/schizophrenia-in-a-beautiful-mind-film/
"Schizophrenia in 'A Beautiful Mind' Film." IvyPanda , 19 Aug. 2020, ivypanda.com/essays/schizophrenia-in-a-beautiful-mind-film/.
IvyPanda . (2020) 'Schizophrenia in 'A Beautiful Mind' Film'. 19 August.
IvyPanda . 2020. "Schizophrenia in 'A Beautiful Mind' Film." August 19, 2020. https://ivypanda.com/essays/schizophrenia-in-a-beautiful-mind-film/.
1. IvyPanda . "Schizophrenia in 'A Beautiful Mind' Film." August 19, 2020. https://ivypanda.com/essays/schizophrenia-in-a-beautiful-mind-film/.
Bibliography
IvyPanda . "Schizophrenia in 'A Beautiful Mind' Film." August 19, 2020. https://ivypanda.com/essays/schizophrenia-in-a-beautiful-mind-film/.
- Schizophrenia: Characteristics, Types and Symptoms
- “A Beautiful Mind” Directed by Ron Howard
- Schizophrenia as a Common Mental Disorder
- Bipolar Disorder in Children: Diagnosis & Therapy
- Schizophrenia Effects on Patient, Caregiver, Society
- Performance Indicators System Study in Healthcare
- Mental Health Care Services for Veterans
- Mental Disabilities: Characteristics and Causes
We Have Beds Available! Call for Same Day Admission. 877-360-1639
We Have Beds Available! Call for Same Day Admission.
877-360-1639
- Residential Programs
- Partial Hospitalization Programs
- Art and Music Therapy
- Biofeedback
- Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
- Dialectical Behavioral Therapy
- Equine Therapy
- Family Therapy
- Motivational Interviewing
- Pet Therapy
- Reality Therapy Program
- Solution-Focused Brief Therapy
- Aftercare Programs
- Ancillary Programs
- Faith-Based Counseling
- Mental Health Care for LGBTQ
- Mental Health Disorder Diagnosis
- Telehealth for Mental Health
- Veterans Program
- Anxiety and Addiction
- Bipolar Disorder and Addiction Treatment
- Addiction and OCD Treatment
- PTSD and Addiction Treatment
- Schizophrenia and Addiction
- Anxiety Treatment
- Bipolar Disorder Treatment
- Depression Treatment
- OCD Treatment
- Schizophrenia Treatment
- Substance-Induced Disorder Treatment
- Thought Disorders
- PTSD Treatment
- Our Locations
- Mental Health Blog
- Mental Health Jobs
- Drug Glossary
- Effectiveness Statistics
- Privacy Policy
Signs of High-Functioning Depression
Best Movies About Mental Illness
How schizophrenia was portrayed in a beautiful mind.
A Beautiful Mind is a movie based on the life of mathematician John Nash and his battle with schizophrenia.
Nash developed the first symptoms of schizophrenia in the 1950s. He later made significant contributions to the field of mathematics, including the math of decision-making and the extension of game theory. His struggles with this mental disorder and its effects on his family were made into a film that has aroused questions regarding schizophrenia. As a mental health care center in Boca , we wanted to analyze how schizophrenia was portrayed in A Beautiful Mind .
What Is Schizophrenia?
Schizophrenia is a chronic mental disorder that affects a person’s thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. This disorder also causes people to feel out of touch with reality. While there are multiple symptoms linked to schizophrenia, the most common include hallucinations, delusions, and difficulties concentrating.
Schizophrenia is a chronic and severe mental illness that can have a detrimental impact on anyone’s life. Without proper care, an individual can lose their life to this disorder. At Banyan Mental Health, we offer schizophrenia treatment that’s led by a team of professionals dedicated to helping patients with this mental disorder.
What Are The Symptoms Of Schizophrenia In A Beautiful Mind
There are several examples of negative symptoms of schizophrenia in A Beautiful Mind , including:
- Delusions of grandeur
- Reduced daily activities
- Neglected hygiene
- Withdrawing from others
- Hallucinations
- Incoherent speech
- Fear of persecution
- Lack of interpersonal relationships
If you or someone you know begins to portray these signs of schizophrenia , we offer different kinds of mental illness treatment in Boca that can help.
What A Beautiful Mind Got Right About Schizophrenia
Many individuals with schizophrenia hear voices or see things that aren’t there and may even seem disconnected from reality or caught up in a different world. While A Beautiful Mind is not an entirely accurate depiction of John Nash’s life, it does offer an accurate representation of schizophrenia.
Delusions of Grandeur
Delusions of grandeur, or grandiose delusions, are among the most common signs of paranoid schizophrenia. This is when a person has an exaggerated sense of significance, personality, authority, or knowledge. In other words, a person displaying this symptom may think and act as if they’re superior to others in different ways. An example of this in A Beautiful Mind is when John offends his other classmates by calling their work “unoriginal,” and claiming that he’ll make something original.
Onset of Symptoms
Although John didn’t begin to show signs of schizophrenia until he was in his 30s, the movie portrayed his symptoms manifesting in his 20s. While this doesn’t accurately depict the course of John’s life, the 20s are the most common period during which schizophrenia reveals itself.
Lack of Emotion
Another common sign of schizophrenia is a change in how a person speaks. In many scenes, including the one where John tells Charles that he “doesn’t like people much,” he shows very little emotion when he speaks. This is frequently portrayed throughout the movie.
Impact of this Disease on a Person’s Life
People with schizophrenia have trouble differentiating fiction from reality, which is accurately portrayed in a scene where John gives a speech about his current research. During this scene, John sees men in suits and believes them to be soviet spies who have been ordered to capture him. Instead, they are really men sent to take him to a psychiatric hospital. John’s delusions advance, causing him to believe that he’s actually working for the Department of Defense under an agent named William Parcher. Eventually, his wife was able to prove to him that none of his letters to the agent were ever opened and that William Parcher never existed.
What A Beautiful Mind Got Wrong About Schizophrenia
While there were plenty of accurately portrayed characteristics of schizophrenia, there were also some that were exaggerated or inaccurate.
There Is No Quick Fix for Schizophrenia
In the movie, it appeared that John only spent a short time in the hospital, receiving treatment and taking the appropriate medication before jumping back into his research; however, this is highly inaccurate. Schizophrenia is a life-long disease that requires consistent therapy and treatment to help the individual adjust and cope with this mental disorder. John Nash himself actually struggled for decades with his mental illness and was unable to work for a long period of time.
While delusions are common side effects of schizophrenia, not all schizophrenics see delusions. Regarding John Nash specifically, he didn’t see delusions like Charles or the soviet spies as they were depicted in the movie, but rather he heard them. Oftentimes, auditory hallucinations – hearing things that aren’t real – can cause delusions. While it can occur, the soviet spies and Nash’s friend Charles can be considered exaggerated symptoms of schizophrenia. These characters help the audience visualize what John was thinking.
Many people have looked into how schizophrenia was portrayed in A Beautiful Mind . Overall, the movie can safely be considered an interesting depiction of a debilitating mental illness that affects the lives of many. If you or someone you know is currently struggling with this mental disorder, call Banyan today at 888-280-4763 for more information about our residential mental health program in Boca .
The Stages of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Anhedonia and Depression
Top 10 Panic Attack Triggers
Related posts
The Truth Behind Vincent van Gogh’s Mental Illness
Schizophrenia: Men vs. Women
High-Functioning Schizophrenia Symptoms
We can help.
We have beds available. call for same day admission..
Verify Insurance
Don’t go! We can help.
Call Now Verify Insurance
Is A Beautiful Mind An Accurate Portrayal Of Schizophrenia?
Attempting to show the struggles of any particular illness on film always involves sensitive elements that need to be handled with care: Be too blasé with the issue, and it may soften the severe battle for those that suffer from it. On the other hand, if you over-embellish certain elements, it can almost skew the common understanding of an illness and stigmatize it for those that deal with it every day. This was the tightrope that Ron Howard and his cast had to walk along when it came to the 2005 film, "A Beautiful Mind." Nominated for eight Academy Awards (via IMDB ) and winning half of them including, Best Picture, Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best Supporting Actress going to Jennifer Connelly , the film told the true story of Nobel Prize-winning mathematician, John Nash, who was diagnosed with schizophrenia.
Russell Crowe took on the demanding and delicate role of Nash, that earned him an Oscar nomination. As impressive as it was, though, just how solid was this portrayal of a man struggling to differentiate reality from his own mental projections? As it turns out, a few elements of Nash's story deviated from the truth in Howard's film. Not because of poor research or consideration, but the medium in which it was displayed.
A decades worth of errors
The 2005 film that told Nash's story, "A Beautiful Mind," sees the mathematician enroll at Princeton University in his early 20s and already showing signs of mental health issues. Awkward around other people and emotionally detached in conversations, Nash shows key signs of someone with this condition, which may be accurate scientifically ... but not necessarily historically, when it comes to Nash himself.
According to the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) , the average age for men showing signs of schizophrenia is in their late teens to early 20s. This would make sense with Nash enduring some of the various uncomfortable situations he finds himself during his time at Princeton, unintentionally belittling his classmates for basic ideas and making jokes that don't quite land. However, Nash wasn't diagnosed until the 1950s, when he was in his early 30s. While Crowe's portrayal in certain environments is correct, it does present issues that may not surfaced for another ten years in Nash's specific case, but which make sense to display on film as a way of indicating his condition.
John's hallucinations shouldn't be seen
Through the tumultuous period of Nash discovering his genius and the condition that impedes him, he meets his good friend and college roommate Charles Herman ( Paul Bettany ). An English student who is fond of parties, women, hangovers and is eventually revealed to be one of Nash's earlier hallucinations. From there, various other characters begin to appear from Nash's creation, including Ed Harris' short-tempered and intense government agent, William Parcher, who "enlists" John's help to uncover codes linked to a Russian plot hidden in the pages of magazines and newspapers.
Nash's encounters with this particular character are heated and have ramifications on those around him, including his wife and child. Creating a tremendous amount of tension in the film and testing Nash's stability as he tries to keep hold of the reality he's slipping from, how it's displayed isn't necessarily accurate to how those with schizophrenia interact with their manifestations.
Speaking to ABC in 2006, Dr. Steve Lamberti, an associate professor of psychiatry at the University of Rochester, explained that "the movie's portrayal of Dr. Nash seeing and conversing with life-like 'people' is not what most individuals who suffer from schizophrenia experience." Instead, a more common symptom is for voices to be heard without warning, with no visual cue of who it belongs to. Also, any seemingly visible display for the sufferer will be a skewed one that is noticeably different from the rest of reality.
Nash's road to recovery is the right one with the occasional wrong turn
The film eventually sees Nash accepting and overcoming his schizophrenia, following his diagnosis and eventual denial of the "people" that he's been interacting with. That being said, elements of Nash's recovery in the film, as harrowing as they are, were sadly correct.
Nash was sent to a psychiatric hospital where he underwent insulin coma therapy, which would lead the patient to have regularly scheduled comas following large doses. The process was eventually discredited and replaced with anti-psychotic drugs. The film also details Nash's relapse after concluding the medication is impeding his work, leading him to deteriorate and, at times, for the hallucinations to return. Lamberti agreed that the film accurately displayed medicine not being the "cure-all" conclusion. That being said, the time spent was far longer for Nash in real life, who fought the condition for decades (via Banyan Mental Health ).
Lamberti also agreed that his family eventually adapting and helping him with his condition did hold truth and is a recommended for those diagnosed. Speaking to ABC, he explained, "the importance of family support has been increasingly recognized in the field of psychiatry over the past 20 years, and new forms of family education and treatment have been developed." Overall, it seems that "A Beautiful Mind" may have applied story mechanics and twists in the timeline to tell Nash's story, but there are enough elements ensuring it was an accurate one, all the same.
Home / Essay Samples / Entertainment / A Beautiful Mind / Analysis Of Schizophrenia In A Beautiful Mind
Analysis Of Schizophrenia In A Beautiful Mind
- Category: Entertainment , Health
- Topic: A Beautiful Mind , Disease , Schizophrenia
Pages: 4 (1671 words)
Views: 2091
- Downloads: -->
Signs and symptoms
Possible etiology, the course of the disorder.
--> ⚠️ Remember: This essay was written and uploaded by an--> click here.
Found a great essay sample but want a unique one?
are ready to help you with your essay
You won’t be charged yet!
Universal Health Care Essays
Substance Abuse Essays
Underage Drinking Essays
Assisted Suicide Essays
Gambling Addiction Essays
Related Essays
We are glad that you like it, but you cannot copy from our website. Just insert your email and this sample will be sent to you.
By clicking “Send”, you agree to our Terms of service and Privacy statement . We will occasionally send you account related emails.
Your essay sample has been sent.
In fact, there is a way to get an original essay! Turn to our writers and order a plagiarism-free paper.
samplius.com uses cookies to offer you the best service possible.By continuing we’ll assume you board with our cookie policy .--> -->