book review my name is red

Thoughts on Papyrus

Exploration of Literature, Cultures & Knowledge

book review my name is red

Review: My Name is Red by Orhan Pamuk

my name is red

A rich, tightly-woven literary tapestry whose secrets lie in elaborate details, red herrings and in the depth of the soul of its maker, celebrating the beauty, imagination and intelligence of ancient artworks and methods of painting. 

“ W hy does man not see things? He is himself standing in the way: he conceals things .” “ What are man’s truths ultimately? Merely his irrefutable errors “. (Friedrich Nietzsche) 

In My Name is Red by Nobel Laureate Orhan Pamuk, the murder of one miniaturist – Elegant Effendi – was committed within the circle of miniaturists working for the Sultan in medieval Istanbul. At the same time, thirty-six year old Black returns to his hometown of Istanbul after the absence of twelve years to seek once again the hand of his beloved Shekure, an opportunity that was denied to him twelve years previously. Unwittingly, Black becomes entangled in the intrigues of miniaturists working under Enishte Effendi, Black’s uncle and Shekure’s father. Masterfully, Pamuk takes us deep within the art circle of medieval craftsmen who labour to produce a mysterious new book, a circle replete with professional jealousy, narcissism, hidden love and, above all, differences as to the proper way of painting and representing pictures under one strict religious canon. In this historical novel, Persian art-forms clash violently with rising Venetian art influences as Black starts to realise that, in order to find the murderer of Elegant Effendi, it is necessary to go deep into the worldviews and art opinions of each of the three suspected miniaturists – “Stork”, “Olive” and “Butterfly”, testing their loyalties and beliefs.

Firstly, My Name is Red is an intriguing murder-mystery that plays with the reader, challenging them to identify the murderer before they reach the end. There are some clues as to the identity of the murderer scattered about in the narrative as we read about secrets that harbour the four great miniaturists – “Stork”, “Olive”, “Butterfly” and murdered Elegant Effendi – while working for the Sultan through both Master Osman and Enishte Effendi. These two masters have different views about the rise in popularity of Venetian art-forms and their influence on their traditional methods of painting.

Who could have killed Elegant Effendi? Another jealous miniaturist? Or maybe a religious fanatic dissatisfied with the way the four miniaturists started working on a new book in secrecy? What is the nature of the new book commissioned by the Sultan? Was it really designed to depict images that go contrary to Islamic faith? Black soon finds himself tasked not only with winning Shekure and her father’s affection, but also finding the murderer as another murder is committed soon afterwards and Shekure feels torn between her allegiance to her brother-in-law (as matrimonial law dictates since her husband has not been declared legally dead) and her devotion to her father. Black realises that, to know the identity of the murderer, it is necessary to go to the earliest foundations of Persian art, its inspirations and consider the nature of its relationship with its western counterpart. Pictures start to speak volumes in the book as Black discovers how past artworks shaped the present miniaturists’ styles and it is here that the answer to the murder puzzle may lie.

“The beauty and mystery of this world only emerges through affection, attention, interest and compassion; if you want to live in that paradise where happy mares and stallions live, open your eyes wide and actually see this world by attending to its colours, details and irony ” [Pamuk/Göknar, 1998/2001: 452].

Two previous books that I reviewed – Mohsin Hamid’s Moth Smoke [2000] and Elif Shafak’s 10 Minutes 38 Seconds in This Strange World [2019] can be compared to My Name is Red since the three most likely drew inspiration from a common source/literary tradition. “Coincidentally”, Shafak’s book 10 Minutes 38 Seconds begins the same way as Pamuk’s My Name is Red – one spirit of a dead person starts talking to us, explaining their curious position and seeking retribution. In My Name is Red, the spirit of dead Elegant Effendi, whose corpse was thrown into a well, starts to recall his life and we get to know his professional circle. Also, as in Mohsin Hamid’s Moth Smoke, My Name is Red presents its story from the multitude of viewpoints, each competing for our attention as we read on and each trying to convince us with its rightness. If in Moth Smoke , there were only three or four other perspectives, in My Name is Red there are perspectives of Black, Shekure, Esther, Enishte Effendi, Master Osman, the three remaining miniaturists, not to mention the perspectives of inanimate objects and animals. The book results in a psychologically-intense ride that presents curious (sometimes black humour) situations that are recounted from different points of view. It is as though Pamuk does not let us see the wood for the trees – as we read on, we are blinded or diverted by different subjective opinions which do not let us see the broader picture or “objective” truth. Paradoxically, we, as readers, are both omniscient as to what is going on and “blind” at the same time because, even though we are cognisant of what is going on in the minds of each of the narrators, we are not told the most important thing and get lost in numerous details of the narration. 

Nizami_-_Khusraw_discovers_Shirin_bathing_in_a_pool

Secondly, My Name is Red is a deep reflection on the nature and the making of art – on its outside influences and development. Pamuk pits the Eastern tradition of art presentation (that puts emphasis on repetition and on the anonymity of artists) against the Western influence (including signatures and portraiture). Many characters in the novel lament the growing “westernisation” of their art, fearing what will be the final consequence regarding their religion and traditions. Something is being lost in their loyalty and devotion to Allah as art starts imitating life too closely (only Allah can be the source of all true creations) and certain unworthy personages take the central stage in paintings.

There are also fears of Ottoman art’s historic roots and old masters’ methods being forgotten and ignored through the vanity of certain miniaturists who want to leave their own signatures or new styles behind. Thus, amidst the murder-mystery, there are also fables told on painters’ styles being equated with mistakes, and on the admirable nature of blindness for artists as Black tries to make sense of this paradox of the trade of making pictures in a Muslim city, hoping it will lead him to the murderer: “ the sincerity of the miniaturist….doesn’t emerge in moments of talent and perfection; on the contrary, it emerges through slips of the tongue, mistakes, fatigues and frustration ” [Pamuk/Göknar, 1998/2001: 243]; “ what exposes us is not the subject, which others have commissioned from us…but the hidden sensibilities we include in the painting as we render that subject ” [Pamuk/Göknar, 1998/2001: 422]; “ a great painter does not content himself by affecting us with his masterpieces; ultimately he succeeds in changing the landscape of our minds ” [Pamuk/Göknar, 1998/2001: 258]. Pamuk lets us step within the beautiful paintings of the old masters of the Ottoman Empire and we walk through the armies and lovers gazing at each other from across the distances, enabling our imagination to fuse with the best paintings made in the Middle East.

There is a third aspect to My Name is Red. We get to know Shekure, the beautiful daughter of Enishte Effendi, quite well – her husband is presumed dead after he marched to war four years ago and she is left with her two young sons. The arrival of Black disrupts her brother-in-law Hasan’s courtship of her and we realise that Black has always been passionately in love with Shekure…or has he? Here, art creeps in once again and life starts imitating art. The subjective nature of love is linked to the subjective viewing of artworks , and Black and Shekure’s courtship is linked to one of the oldest Persian fables – Hüsrev and Shirin by Persian poet Nizami Ganjavi, as well as to the falling in love with the presentation of the image of one’s beloved first: “ love…must be understood, not through the logic, but through its illogic ” [1998/2001: 658]. The colour red subtly creeps in and repeats itself where we find ourselves closer to truth. Red stands for blood and violence, but also for passion as Black’s lust becomes uncontrollable even though his heart remains “pure” like that of a child: “ for if a lover’s face survives emblazoned on your heart, the world is still your home” [1998/2001: 49]. Satan and Death both have their say in this book too – “ what we essentially want is to draw something unknown to us in all its shadowiness, not something we know in all its illumination ” [1998/2001: 202], and, by the end, the book becomes one unforgettable adventure into the mysteries of art, life, love and death.

🕌 The conclusion is that My Name is Red , translated from the Turkish by Erdağ Göknar, is an evocative, richly-layered and vivid murder-mystery with one unusual structure that immerses us into the mysteries of Ottoman paintings and in the atmosphere of medieval Istanbul. It is a true page-turner steeped in the history of the Ottoman art where fables and reality, as well as life and art, inexplicably merge to produce a one-of-a-kind story. 

Share this:

23 thoughts on “ review: my name is red by orhan pamuk ”.

Great review, Diana! I always enjoy your layered analyses of what you read. This sounds like it’ll be right up my alley – a murder mystery AND a book about art in a medieval setting? I can’t resist that combination. Hopefully I can obtain a copy this month. (Also, this is completely unrelated and trivial but my curiosity has reached a breaking point and I have to ask – what’s the citation style you’re using? I’ve never encountered it before, but it looks like a parsimonious way to reference books.)

Like Liked by 1 person

Thanks! I hope you enjoy this book! Citation style? I guess it is a variation on in-text Cambridge University Press.

Great review, adding this on my TBR.

This book looks incredibly interesting. And I love unique settings for murder mysteries, but the idea of a lush setting and the perspective of the victim himself is fascinating! I really enjoyed reading this review and will definitely be putting the book on my TBR.

Thanks a lot, and I hope you enjoy the book. It is very good, but quite unusual too.

You’ve understood this book so well. I tried to read it twice and failed both times, about two-thirds of the way through. Third time lucky as they say.

I hope you manage to read it third time. It is not an easy read but I thought it did tie things up nicely at the end.

Lovely review, Diana! You’ve reminded me I need to get ahold of this book 🙂

A fascinating and in-depth review. I have been meaning to read Pamuk, and this helps to persaud me.

I love your reviews Diana…I have been eyeing this book for a long time and definitely now I will get it. I have to admit I skim-read this so that I didn’t find out too much of the plot. The setting, characters, Pulitzer and your five stars won me over completely! Thank you 😊

I hope you like the book! I hardly put any plot and especially not spoilers in my reviews – but just try to talk about general themes. Somehow, in worrying times such as these, I reach not for comfort books, but the opposite – it seems, hmm.

I think I know what you mean…I feel the same too. Having books that are explainers or give some kind of clarity and address the situation going on, this can be such a comfort too. The book Black Swan by Nicholas Taleb is a good one for this, I don’t know if you have read that one, but it’s about the unforeseen scenarios like the one we are in right now. It is very difficult to read but also very comforting in a way, if you know what I mean.

Agreeing with everyone else, a great review. My Name is Red was my first Pamuk book, though it was Maureen Freely’s translation.

Thanks! I didn’t even know of that other translation, and it is certainly a great book to begin with this author.

  • Pingback: The Mid-Year Book Freak-Out Tag – Thoughts on Papyrus
  • Pingback: July 2020 Wrap-Up – Thoughts on Papyrus

I’m so glad to read your review. I read Pamuk’s Snow many years ago and was extremely impressed with the prose but found the story difficult to get through. Last year we hosted an exchange student from Istanbul and she encouraged me to give him another try. However, she had no recommendations. Now I’ll add My Name is Red to my TBR list. Thanks much!

Thank you for reading! I hope you like My Name is Red. I think that there is a little bit of everything there for every kind of reader – those who love history, those who love romance, those who love paintings, those who love murder mysteries, etc., and, of course, it is all rendered in Pamuk’s beautiful language (even if it is in translation). It is probably his best book. Since you love his prose, I can also suggest Pamuk’s The Black Book (if you have not read it already) – that one is very meditative, eerie and thought-provoking (it has something very special inside), even if the plot itself is a bit underwhelming.

  • Pingback: 7 Great Novels Revolving Around Visual Art – Thoughts on Papyrus
  • Pingback: Translated Literature Recommendations – Thoughts on Papyrus
  • Pingback: 7 Unputdownable Books Written from Multiple “First-Person” Perspectives – Thoughts on Papyrus
  • Pingback: Review: A Strangeness in My Mind by Orhan Pamuk – Thoughts on Papyrus
  • Pingback: Nobel Laureates for Literature: My Stats & Preferences – Thoughts on Papyrus

Leave a comment Cancel reply

' src=

  • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
  • Subscribe Subscribed
  • Copy shortlink
  • Report this content
  • View post in Reader
  • Manage subscriptions
  • Collapse this bar

The Bibliofile

Advertise   Contact   Privacy

Browse All Reviews

New Releases

List Reviews by Rating

List Reviews by Author

List Reviews by Title

My Name is Red by Orhan Pamuk

My Name Is Red

By orhan pamuk, a philosophical art mystery.

Huh. I liked this book in theory. My Name is Red reads like a philosophical mystery, except it’s only about art philosophy. It’s a story about a murder among a group of miniaturists (which are basically artists), and it is set in the Ottoman Empire. The book itself was originally written in Turkish.

The idea is that they are working on book of illustrations that reflects a style that is considered to be sacrilegious in that it is considered idolatry, detracting from the glorification of God, etc. Among them, there has been a murder of one of the miniaturists. There’s more to the plot line than just this, but the main crux of the novel is how the main character, Black, investigates by speaking to the suspects regarding their views on various aspects of art, while at the same time the unidentified murderer discusses his thoughts as well.

Theoretically, you should be trying to figure out who is the murderer based on these discussions of art philosophy. It was good in terms of writing, pacing, etc., but I think my appreciation of this book is largely on an academic level. If you think you’d enjoy theoretical discourses on art, for example considering what “is” art and whether things like personal style detracts from art and the representation of “truth,” then you’d probably love this book. It might be a little inaccessible to some, but it’s definitely worth a read for art lovers or anyone looking to venture into very well-written, but unfamiliar territory.

Share this post

Bookshelf -- A literary set collection game

The Housemaid is Watching

She’s Not Sorry

The Seven Year Slip

Darling Girls

Yours Truly

Best Literary Fiction of 2024 (New & Anticipated)

The Housemaid Book Series Recap

2024’s Best Book Club Books (New & Anticipated)

Bookshelf: Development Diary

Best Rom-Com, Beach Reads & Contemporary Romance Books

book review my name is red

Share your thoughts Cancel reply

book review my name is red

My Name Is Red

Orhan Pamuk and Erdag Gokna | 3.93 | 44,378 ratings and reviews

Ranked #2 in Turkey , Ranked #3 in Turkish — see more rankings .

Rankings by Category

My Name Is Red is ranked in the following categories:

  • #99 in Copenhagen
  • #83 in Dublin
  • #45 in Middle East
  • #24 in Nobel

Similar Books

If you like My Name Is Red, check out these similar top-rated books:

book review my name is red

Learn: What makes Shortform summaries the best in the world?

  • Biggest New Books
  • Non-Fiction
  • All Categories
  • First Readers Club Daily Giveaway
  • How It Works

book review my name is red

My Name is Red

book review my name is red

Embed our reviews widget for this book

book review my name is red

Get the Book Marks Bulletin

Email address:

  • Categories Fiction Fantasy Graphic Novels Historical Horror Literary Literature in Translation Mystery, Crime, & Thriller Poetry Romance Speculative Story Collections Non-Fiction Art Biography Criticism Culture Essays Film & TV Graphic Nonfiction Health History Investigative Journalism Memoir Music Nature Politics Religion Science Social Sciences Sports Technology Travel True Crime

May 31, 2024

june jordan

  • June Jordan’s 1993 tribute to her friend and fellow activist, Audre Lorde
  • Why it’s harder than ever for debut writers to break out
  • What Keila Shaheen’s self-published best-seller The Shadow Work Journal reveals about TikTok and publishing

That's What She Read

Review: My Name Is Red by Orhan Pamuk

book review my name is red

Orhan Pamuk has been on my list of writers to sample for a while. I started with My Name Is Red because its focus on illuminated manuscripts appealed to me. I disregarded the reviews which suggested this is not the ‘best’ place to start with Pamuk. Alas, I was cocky. I thought my knowledge of history, memories of Istanbul, and hours spent copying/painting manuscripts would give me a leg up. They didn’t. I’ve read books set in unfamiliar cultures before, but My Name Is Red feels truly foreign and reminiscent of that moment in Istanbul when I realized Turkish is a tricky language. But instead of squinting at signs, I was scratching my head at Pamuk’s mythical, artistic, and philosophical diversions. In all cases, something was familiar, but I was miles away.

From the back cover: At once a fiendishly devious mystery, a beguiling love story, and a brilliant symposium on the power of art,  My Name Is Red is a transporting tale set amid the splendor and religious intrigue of sixteenth-century Istanbul. The Sultan has commissioned a cadre of the most acclaimed artists in the land to create a great book celebrating the glories of his realm. Their task: to illuminate the work in the European style. But because figurative art can be deemed an affront to Islam, this commission is a dangerous proposition indeed. And when one of the chosen miniaturists disappears, the only clue to the mystery lies in the half-finished illuminations themselves. Part fantasy and part philosophical puzzle,  My Name Is Red is a kaleidoscope journey into the intersection of art, religion, love, sex, and power.

There are scenes in this book that don’t require outside knowledge to appreciate. The story is told from a rotating set of perspectives that includes a corpse, dog, gold coin, and various illustrations. Chapters are titled “I Am a Corpse,” “I Am Called Black,” “I Am a Dog,” “I Will Be Called a Murderer,” and so on. The language/tone is regulated so that even reading the perspective of the murdered man and the murderer isn’t enough for a reader to sniff out the guilty party. There are particularly brilliant moments when the perspective shifts within a scene to allow multiple characters to comment in the moment rather than through retrospectives. There’s something cinematic about this: I imagine a camera moving around a room, changing views, zooming in, then panning out. When drawings or props speak, they offer new angles on their owners so everyone is seen inside and out, even if they’re alone. A favorite section is narrated by a gold coin and begins grandly:

Behold! I am a twenty-two-carat Ottoman Sultani gold coin and I bear the glorious insignia of His Excellency Our Sultan, Refuge of the World. … Hello, hello, greetings to all the master artists and assorted guests. Your eyes widen as you behold my glimmer, you thrill as I shimmer in the light of the oil lamp, and finally you bristle with envy at my owner. (102)

But gives way to a woeful confession:

All right then, I confess. I’m not a genuine twenty-two-carat Ottoman Sultani gold coin minted at the Chemberlitash Mint. I’m counterfeit. They made me in Venice using adulturated gold and brought me here, passing me off as twenty-two-carat Ottoman gold. Your sympathy and understanding are much obliged. (103)

This gold coin—with its humble secret, grand tales of being passed through the streets of Istanbul, and fear of being hoarded in a jar—has more (and better) ‘character’ development than human characters in crummy novels.

I enjoy this kind of diversion because the coin’s journey produced memorable descriptions of the people and city. Other meanderings have less obvious pay-offs. Pamuk includes a fair amount of myths and stories. Some read like Aesop’s fables, but the morals given at their close will not be familiar to western audiences. They take time from a cleverly built whodunnit, but their thematic framework illuminates the main action.  My Name Is Red is plainly written for a Turkish audience (and it’s written in Turkish), but these stories allow it to be intelligible to a western audience as well.

The philosophy and mystery are great, but the love triangle is a shaky business. The woman, Shekure, must choose between her brother-in-law whom she dislikes (her husband is missing, presumed dead) and her old flame. She’s clearly written by a man and I had a hard time taking her seriously. Also strange is the fact that Shekure’s two children are named Shevket and Orhan. Shevket is the name of Orhan Pamuk’s older brother in real life, Shekure is the name of his mother, and Orhan is his own first name. Does this mean something? So glad to be out of school—this is the kind of thing that would require an essay on my least favorite subject: authorial intent.

(“What does this mean?” is the theme of this review by the way.)

Looking at the back cover now, I see the mystery is given little mention next to the talk of art. This book is more easily sold to a philosopher/artist/historian than someone looking for a cerebral mystery to take to the beach (where I read a portion). As such, it’s hard to summarize, but if you’re into these subjects and have time to read slowly and carefully, I expect you’ll be impressed by  My Name Is Red .

Overall: 4.2 (out of 5.0) This book was more difficult than expected and I suspect it was largely wasted on me, but even I can see the tremendous writing skill. The balance of voices is extraordinary and, even though the mystery is a much smaller element than I wanted, the diversions were thoughtfully and beautifully phrased (if not well-paced).

Translation: Help me find another book by Pamuk. He’s plainly worth reading, but I’m not sure this was the one for me.

Share this:

11 thoughts on “review: my name is red by orhan pamuk”.

This was my first read of Pamuk and I struggled with it. I then read Snow, which was much more my kind of book and I recommend it, The Museum of Innocence drove me cray with its repetition and length despite being well written, and ‘Istanbul’ is probably my favourite because I read it just after visiting that city – although my visit and impressions were a lot more upbeat than Pamuk’s, which are rather melancholic. Do try another anyway.

Thanks for the recommendations! I think Istanbul will be an interesting read after My Name Is Red because it sounds like it’s written in a radically different style. It sounds like it’s rooted in the modern era, even as it looks back through history. My favorite sections of My Name Is Red were the ones in which Pamuk stepped away from metaphor/philosophy and created something that felt tangible. HIs writing is so strong that I was amazed at how easy it was to envision a world so foreign to me.

Like you and Claire I started with My Name Is Red and loved it. From there I liked Snow but more than it, I loved the Museum of Innocence!!! I loved its obsessional love, it’s edgy feel of fascination that is almost overpowering but not quite and I LOVED that repetition!!! But if you’re looking for where to next I’d recommend his most recent book ‘A Strangeness In My Mind’ about a Boza seller in Istanbul – its brilliantly written and the city of Istanbul absolutely leaps off the page throughout!

Lol–now I’m torn on The Museum of Innocence since there’s now one excited vote and one cautionary vote! 🙂 It’s easy to think of repetitive books I’ve loved, but also some I’ve loathed. On the upside, they’re very skimmable when they take a turn towards redundancy. I have a terrible habit of missing the one relevant sentence when I skip though… A Strangeness in My Mind sounds very good. That’s actually the first Pamuk book I ran across, but the mystery aspect of My Name Is Red won me over since I’ve been on a mystery kick these last couple months. Thanks for the recommendations! Pamuk writes so beautifully that I can’t wait to read his others.

I’m glad I’m not the only one who struggled with this book! I started off totally in awe, ended in awe, but had a tough time in between. The concept, the language, the descriptions were fascinating though. I will one day revisit this author…

Me too! I read it over a period of months and set a date for this review just to give myself a deadline. Reading it in stops/starts made it easier to appreciate the writing since I could set it down anytime I felt overwhelmed or impatient. It feels strange to be simultaneously impressed by an author yet unable to read more than a few chapters at time.

I am lucky that I have been able to read Orhan Pamuk both in Turkish and in English (superb translations by Maureen Freely). He is an incredible writer. I agree that at times reading his books may seem strenuous ( in a good way), but I laso feel that the reward one feels at the end makes it all worthwhile. One ends up being enriched from the experience. After reading The Museum of Innocence ( an easier read than the My Name is Red mentioned widely here which I truly loved but could only read in bouts) my husband and I actually travelled to Istanbul to visit the museum. Seeing the objects described in the book, an amazing display of more than 4200 cigarette butts, Kemal’s room, Fusun’s dress gave me goose bumps. I was so overwhelmed that I actually became emotional. It really was an amazing experience! A Strangeness in My Mind is my favourite. He wrote another book after this one called The woman with Red Hair ( equally good)but as far as I know it hasn ,t been translated into English yet.

How wonderful! Do think much is lost in the translations of Pamuk’s work? Does Freely really get the same voice and tone as the Turkish original? There were so many voices in My Name Is Read that it couldn’t have been easy to write or translate!

The Museum of Innocence is definitely on my list to read. I think A Strangeness in My Mind will probably be the last one I pick up… I like working up to an author’s “best” and it’s the one that most appeals to me. I feel like I should get a better understanding of his writing style and pacing before reading it to have more appreciation for it. 🙂

That’s exactly what I was thinking when I read My name is Red. It must have been a very difficult book to write. I was curious to know how long it took him to finish the book.Then I came across one of his lesser known books ” Manzaradan Parcalar” literally translated as “Fragments of the View”an autobiographical account of his life and his books. (I hope it will get translated one day ) There is a chapter in which he says that it took him years to formulate the story in his head and to carry out the background research and four years of actively writing it. He delightfully describes the day he finally finished the book and went out and treated himself to two expensive shirts and a not so expensive chicken doner kebab I thought I will share that with you. Happy reading! Nilgun

Four years of active writing is quite a lot. No wonder My Name Is Read is so intricate! I hope this book is translated some day. Thanks for sharing. 🙂

You should read ‘a strangeness in my mind’. Its known as Orhans love letter to Istanbul and after you’ve read it, you’ll soon see why. It’s such a beautiful and nostalgic love story. It was the first book I read by him, and now I am obsessed with orhan pamuk.

I’ve also read my name is red, and I too, am not sure I completely got it. I might give it another go after reading your review. There was a clever riddle in there somewhere. I wish I knew about the culture and history.

Please check out my review on ‘the White Castle.’ It’s not like his other books. Firstly, it’s not the mammoth size of his other books, and secondly it doesn’t have that hopelessly romantic feel like his other books. However it’s really clever and witty and just shines with brilliance.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed .

Discover more from That's What She Read

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Literary Theory and Criticism

Home › Literature › Analysis of Orhan Pamuk’s My Name is Red

Analysis of Orhan Pamuk’s My Name is Red

By NASRULLAH MAMBROL on August 2, 2023

My Name Is Red , the recipient of the International Impac Dublin Literary Award in 2003, is perhaps the most celebrated book by the Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk (1952– ), who won the Nobel Prize in literature in 2006. The novel, which is superficially a murder mystery, details the artistic and philosophical conflicts that surround Ottoman miniaturist painters during the 16th century.

Pamuk tells his story through a number of short chapters spoken in the voices of different narrators that range from inanimate objects drawn on paper to the central characters (including Enishte, a miniaturist commissioned by the sultan to produce a secret book of illustrations; his daughter Shekure; and his nephew Black, who returns from exile in the East). The different voices, and the novel itself, further the contemporary Turkish debate over the impact of Western culture as Turkey seeks to create a coherent identity for its multicultural populace. In addition to the main story, the reader is presented with a subplot: The rekindling of the childhood love between Black and Shekure provides a glimpse of a woman’s life in the Ottoman Empire. Well aware of Enishte’s declining reputation and popularity among fellow miniaturists due to the secret book, Black takes it upon himself to protect himself and his daughter. In this way he hopes to win Shekure’s heart and convince her of a speedy divorce from her estranged husband in order for him to marry her.

book review my name is red

Orhan Pamuk Via Border Kitchen

The first narrative belongs to the corpse of a miniaturist in the Ottoman court, Elegant Efendi, who reveals that his death is a result of religious conspiracy designed to suppress the artistic innovations introduced from the West. Both Elegant and Enishte have been attentive to the new forms of painting in the West. In their attempts to incorporate Western portraiture into their traditional miniatures, they anger extremists who perceive the West as a threat to the preservation of Ottoman culture.

By foregrounding the discrepancy between the Eastern and Western modes of seeing and representing, Pamuk sets the stage for a discussion of the conflicts that have influenced the relationship between East and West. He also observes how different artistic visions can become political matters in a society struggling to find its identity amid tensions between liberals and conservatives. While progressive miniaturists are enthusiastic about incorporating Western techniques, the fundamentalists condemn the West’s emphasis on originality, individual style, and autonomous subject matter, fearing that such depictions are sacrilegious.

A mouthpiece for extreme conservatism, the murderer, whose voice we hear without learning his identity, maintains that miniature painting should stick to the basic philosophical principles of Islamic decorum. In Islam, painting is deemed blasphemous, for the Koran explicitly prohibits pictorial representations to avoid idolatry. Within strict parameters, Muslim artists work with sophisticated forms of gilding, ornamentation, and miniature—the only acceptable forms of representational art. The art of miniature compels the artist to represent visually the symbolic rather than individual nature of objects, adopting an elevated viewpoint to emulate the way Allah sees the world from above. Any challenge to these principles, according to the murderer, is an affront to religion. The characters who remain open to change, like Enishte and Elegant, also consider themselves devout Muslims, but they explain that their effort to embrace foreign innovations does not reflect a desire to become Westernized; rather, they believe that artistic traditions are better served by incorporating difference.

The separation between the affairs of the state and religion, in this and other novels, is crucial for Pamuk, who believes that religion is a private practice that should therefore have no weight in political discussions. Pamuk identifies secularism as a condition of modernity. The insider/outsider binary of religion, he observes, often threatens the fundamental principles of a multicultural society.

My Name Is Red is a testament to the crisis of identity that the Ottomans suffered and bequeathed to modern Turkey. Pamuk indicates the futility of the fundamentalist position, underlining that cultural exchange should not be equated with loss of identity; on the contrary, just as the Ottoman miniaturists have borrowed from the masters of Herat in the East to perfect their techniques, they should also recognize the value in innovations from the West. Liberal artists such as Elegant and Enishte understand the value of harmonizing different ways of seeing. For this reason, Enishte’s acceptance of the sultan’s commission is not just an artistic endeavor, but a political act that advocates a more productive relationship between East and West, and Elegant’s murder is a warning about the extremes to which some will go to prevent that new relationship from taking root.

Analysis of Orhan Pamuk’s The Black Book

BIBLIOGRAPHY Freeman, John. “In Snow, an Apolitical Poet Mirrors Apolitical Pamuk.” Village Voice, 17 August 2004. Pamuk, Orhan. “The Anger of the Damned.” New York Review of Books 18. 15 November 2001. ———. The Black Book. Translated by Güneli Gün. San Diego: Harcourt Brace, 1996. ———. “Freedom to Write.” New York Review of Books, 25 May 2006. ———. Istanbul: Memories of a City. Translated by Maureen Freely. London: Faber and Faber, 2005.

Share this:

Categories: Literature , Mystery Fiction , Novel Analysis , Turkish Literature

Tags: Analysis of Orhan Pamuk's My Name Is Red , Appreciation of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red , Essays of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red , Guide of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red , My Name Is Red , Notes of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red , Orhan Pamuk , Orhan Pamuk's My Name Is Red , Plot of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red , Review of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red , Structure of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red , Summary of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red , Themes of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red

You must be logged in to post a comment.

My Name is Red by Orhan Pamuk

general information | review summaries | our review | links | about the author

- Return to top of the page -

A- : beguiling, if also a bit laboured

See our review for fuller assessment.

   Review Consensus :   Impressed, and quite a few find it absolutely brilliant    From the Reviews : "While My Name Is Red has a many-layered plot -- including a murder mystery and a love story -- its thematic value is threefold: to provide a glimpse into an Islamic society, to understand the global tensions that exist when one empire waxes while another wanes, and to point out the cyclical nature of history." - Char Simons, Christian Science Monitor "Less forgivable, however, is the fact that his various suspects are insufficiently differentiated from each other, so that in the end we simply don't care who the murderer is. In a lesser novel this would be a terminal flaw. But no writer as elusive as Pamuk can write an uninteresting book, and as a meditation on art, in particular, My Name Is Red is exquisitely subtle, demanding and repaying the closest attention." - Tom Holland, Daily Telegraph "It is an enlightening, though eerie, experience to read this book at the present moment. For its theme is a clash of cultures -- between a religious tradition which subordinates man to God, and a new-fangled individualism which places man at the centre of the universe." - The Economist "Rot ist freilich auch die Farbe der Liebe. Pamuks verwirrend schöner Roman erzählt deshalb, wie fast jeder gute Kriminalroman, zugleich eine wunderbare Liebesgeschichte. (...) Dieser Roman ist ein wunderbar reiches Stück Weltliteratur." - Ernst Osterkamp, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung "This is a novel of ideas and a meditation on how east and west might meet. It is also an example of what has been a popular genre in recent decades: the historical mystery." - John Mullan, The Guardian "Man wird nicht müde, Pamuk zu lesen, denn wieder hat er ein sprachliches Kunstwerk geschaffen, schildert in tausendundein Farben ein Intrigenspiel um Liebe und Tod, um Tradition und den Aufbruch in die Moderne, das in vergangenen osmanischen Zeiten handelt und doch auf das Heute abzielt." - Monika Carbe, Neue Zürcher Zeitung "He has taken his inspiration from western modernist literature, but instead of destroying his 16th-century artists, he illuminates their world as no one has before. (...) More than any other book I can think of, it captures not just its past and present contradictions, but also its terrible, timeless beauty. It's almost perfect, in other words." - Maureen Freely, New Statesman " My Name Is Red is not just a novel of ideas. Eastern or Western, good or bad, ideas precipitate once they sink to human level, unleashing passions and violence. Red is chockful of sublimity and sin. (...) To sum up, and each time the sums come out different: the ideas in Red give fascination and energy, and work to hold together its turbulent narrative. They work and they fail; and in a way, though not entirely, the failure is Pamuk's success." - Richard Eder, The New York Times Book Review "Pamuk, however, is not at all didactic; rather, he simply displays the cultural dynamics at work. As in Faulkner's As I Lay Dying , the story's baton is handed from one character to another and moves through time, producing a clever narrative scheme we only wholly grasp on the last page." - Allen Hibbard, Review of Contemporary Fiction "(A) huge and ambitious novel that is by turns charming and pedantic. (...) Here, the ingredients are potent, but the balance is off. Like an overenthusiastic master illustrator, Pamuk paints a vivid picture, but loads it with so many details and symbols that the eye has nowhere calm to rest." - Sarah Coleman, San Francisco Chronicle "This novel is then formally brilliant, witty and about serious matters. But even this inclusive description does not really capture what I feel is the book's true greatness, which lies in its managing to do with apparent ease what novelists have always striven for but very few achieve. It conveys in a wholly convincing manner the emotional, cerebral and physical texture of daily life, and it does so with great compassion, generosity and humanity." - Dick Davis, Times Literary Supplement Please note that these ratings solely represent the complete review 's biased interpretation and subjective opinion of the actual reviews and do not claim to accurately reflect or represent the views of the reviewers. Similarly the illustrative quotes chosen here are merely those the complete review subjectively believes represent the tenor and judgment of the review as a whole. We acknowledge (and remind and warn you) that they may, in fact, be entirely unrepresentative of the actual reviews by any other measure.

The complete review 's Review :

My death conceals an appalling conspiracy against our religion, our traditions and the way we see the world.

About the Author :

       Internationally acclaimed Turkish author Orhan Pamuk was born in 1952. He was awarded the Nobel Prize for literature in 2006.

© 2004-2022 the complete review Main | the New | the Best | the Rest | Review Index | Links

Kara.Reviews

Review of My Name Is Red by Orhan Pamuk

My Name Is Red

by Orhan Pamuk

This is the second work of historical fiction I’ve read in a month that has a colour in its title and features art as a significant component of its story. The other, Sacré Bleu , was an irreverent “comedy d’art” by Christopher Moore. My Name is Red definitely isn’t that. Good thing I like to read widely!

My Name is Red opens with the voice of a dead man. Elegant Effendi describes the sensations of knowing he is dead, of his spirit decoupling from his body. He hopes his murderer will be found and brought to justice (the more creative the better). From there, Orhan Pamuk goes on to hop perspectives every chapter, weaving a story of magic and mystery in sixteenth-century Istanbul. Centred around a workshop of miniaturists who are working on a somewhat controversial book for the Sultan, My Name is Red dips into some of the questions raised in the sixteenth century as the Ottoman Empire continued to coexist uneasily next to the Christian nations of Western Europe. The time is the past and the setting is, as always, that battleground between change and tradition.

This book reminds me a lot of The Name of the Rose . Superficially they have so many similarities: both are translations, one from Turkish and one from Italian. Both are set in the past and involve a murder mystery. Both are written in a style that is, if not challenging, then definitely demanding of one’s full attention. Beyond the surface, though, the striking similarities continue: both of these novels are about the tension between different schools of thought. In The Name of the Rose it’s the growing chasm between science and religion, between the empirical principles of Bacon and Occam and the spiritual communion of the Franciscans and Dominicans. In My Name is Red it’s the clash between the older, traditional ways of depicting people in Islamic art and the new style imported from Venice—a style that, some worry, comes too close to the real thing. And in both these novels, the murders are inextricably linked to these questions of style, change, and tradition.

I can see why many people express frustration over this book’s narration. It’s not the easiest book to read. Translated from Turkish, My Name is Red doesn’t always have the same kind of unity and coherence that a novel originally written in English might have. Moreover, Pamuk has very little time for dialogue. Most of the book is either description or introspection from the narrator to the reader. My Name is Red reminds me of a stage play. In each scene, several actors would be in tableaux while the narrator of the scene delivers an extensive monologue. Then, with a flourish, he or she triggers the action, the other actors unfreeze, and the plot drags forward for a few minutes before the narrator re-assumes control. Although i understand why some people see the narrators as flat, I thought the moments when they comment on their actions, their drawings or letter-writing or courting, were quite confessional. Just the character and I in a musty, dark room, as the character hurriedly scribbles out the journal of their last days. One of them is a murderer ….

Thanks to the way Pamuk structures the novel, attempting to discover the identity of the murderer is half the fun. The murderer narrates both as himself and as his ordinary miniaturist alter ego, always careful never to reveal anything about his actions as a miniaturist that would shed light on his identity. So, for example, Pamuk has each of the three suspect miniaturists tell three parables labelled Aliph, Bet, Djim, allowing the murderer to refer to these stories without revealing which miniaturist he is. But the clues are there, getting louder as the novel approaches the climax and the identity of the murderer is revealed. I was sure it was one miniaturist pretty early on—and I was wrong. So it goes.

The miniaturists’ chapters are also very interesting looks at the ongoing debate regarding Islamic versus Western art. Is it sacrilege to paint in the Frankish style? What is style, anyway? Is it sacrilege to have one’s own style, rather than labouring to faithfully reproduce the old pieces as flawlessly as possible? True flawlessness, of course, just like true creativity, is the domain of Allah and not something a mere human artist could achieve. These questions spill over beyond the miniaturists’ chapters, however, and into the concurrent love story between Shekure and Black and the murder mystery itself. The ideas Pamuk juggles are particularly appropriate to the context of the story, but they are timeless and still relevant today.

Above all else, Pamuk manages to convey how personal the process of making and rendering art can be. Making art is a thoughtful, time-consuming activity that can be as emotionally draining as it is physically. The crises of faith experienced in My Name is Red are all too real. They happen as a result of the expression of self necessary for art to be possible: what you make, and how you make it, says something about yourself and your convictions, what you believe and the values you hold dear. To set that down on paper, in ink, in stone, on canvas, for others to view and discuss and rip apart … it’s a little terrifying. Worse still, in the act of such creation, you begin to think about these beliefs and sometimes even question them—or, through the influence of other creators, you realize that there are other sets of beliefs out there. Which ones are true, better, practical, enriching, etc.? Does it even matter?

So, you know, art is serious business. Serious enough in this case that someone was willing to kill Elegant Effendi for questioning if what they were doing was compatible with the wishes of Allah. On one hand, such actions seem like the same old, same old internecine and destructive effects of organized religion—but that would be a disingenuous and uncharitable evaluation. For on the other hand, the conflict in My Name is Red is less about religion and more about personal values that hinge upon the intersection of history, politics, faith, and art.

It took me a while to read My Name is Red , partly because I did so while moving to another country and partly because of its heavily stylized narration. But read it I did. While it did not necessarily excite me or enthrall me in the same way The Name of the Rose did, its meditations on the nature of art and artistry, style and sacrilege and sacrifice, are still interesting. It is a deep and thoughtful book; as long as you are willing to spend the time and effort on it, it is also a rewarding one.

Share on the socials

Twitter Facebook

Let me know what you think

Goodreads Logo

Enjoying my reviews?

Profile Picture

  • ADMIN AREA MY BOOKSHELF MY DASHBOARD MY PROFILE SIGN OUT SIGN IN

avatar

MY NAME IS RED

by Orhan Pamuk & translated by Erdag Göknar ‧ RELEASE DATE: Sept. 6, 2001

A rich feast of ideas, images, and lore.

Acclaimed Turkish writer Pamuk ( The New Life , 1997, etc.) investigates two brutal murders—and offers a whimsical but provocative exploration of the nature of art in an Islamic society.

My Name is Red speaks in many voices, some more predominant than others. A dog, a tree, and a horse as well as Death, Satan, and a corpse all make eloquent contributions to the narrative, but center stage are Black the clerk, the Murderer, Esther the Jewish matchmaker, and Shekure, recently married to Black. The setting is Istanbul in the late 1500s—a period of time that saw the Ottoman Empire at its height but increasingly challenged by the innovative West. Prohibited by the Koran to paint realistic likenesses, the Islamic miniaturists of Istanbul have for centuries done stylized pictures of people, plants, and horses. Their informing belief has been that art should reflect what Allah sees from above, but when a new Sultan commissions a book from noted artist Enishte Effendi that will include a portrait of the Sultan in the Western style, reactionary artists and mullahs become alarmed. After a noted engraver and Enishte are found murdered, the Sultan demands the killer be found or all the miniaturists will be put to death. Black, Enishte’s nephew, becomes involved in the investigation. He consults with the famous miniaturist Master Osman, who senses that an era is ending and blinds himself, as well as with the artists working on the book with his late uncle Enishte. With nicknames like Butterfly, Stork, and Olive, these artists reminisce and discuss the difference between Western and Islamic art while proclaiming their innocence. Threatened with torture by the Sultan, Black finally gets his man—not to mention the respect of his new bride.

Pub Date: Sept. 6, 2001

ISBN: 0-375-40695-6

Page Count: 384

Publisher: Knopf

Review Posted Online: May 19, 2010

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 1, 2001

LITERARY FICTION

Share your opinion of this book

More by Orhan Pamuk

NIGHTS OF PLAGUE

BOOK REVIEW

by Orhan Pamuk ; translated by Ekin Oklap

THE RED-HAIRED WOMAN

Awards & Accolades

Readers Vote

Our Verdict

Our Verdict

Kirkus Reviews' Best Books Of 2019

New York Times Bestseller

IndieBound Bestseller

NORMAL PEOPLE

by Sally Rooney ‧ RELEASE DATE: April 16, 2019

Absolutely enthralling. Read it.

A young Irish couple gets together, splits up, gets together, splits up—sorry, can't tell you how it ends!

Irish writer Rooney has made a trans-Atlantic splash since publishing her first novel, Conversations With Friends , in 2017. Her second has already won the Costa Novel Award, among other honors, since it was published in Ireland and Britain last year. In outline it's a simple story, but Rooney tells it with bravura intelligence, wit, and delicacy. Connell Waldron and Marianne Sheridan are classmates in the small Irish town of Carricklea, where his mother works for her family as a cleaner. It's 2011, after the financial crisis, which hovers around the edges of the book like a ghost. Connell is popular in school, good at soccer, and nice; Marianne is strange and friendless. They're the smartest kids in their class, and they forge an intimacy when Connell picks his mother up from Marianne's house. Soon they're having sex, but Connell doesn't want anyone to know and Marianne doesn't mind; either she really doesn't care, or it's all she thinks she deserves. Or both. Though one time when she's forced into a social situation with some of their classmates, she briefly fantasizes about what would happen if she revealed their connection: "How much terrifying and bewildering status would accrue to her in this one moment, how destabilising it would be, how destructive." When they both move to Dublin for Trinity College, their positions are swapped: Marianne now seems electric and in-demand while Connell feels adrift in this unfamiliar environment. Rooney's genius lies in her ability to track her characters' subtle shifts in power, both within themselves and in relation to each other, and the ways they do and don't know each other; they both feel most like themselves when they're together, but they still have disastrous failures of communication. "Sorry about last night," Marianne says to Connell in February 2012. Then Rooney elaborates: "She tries to pronounce this in a way that communicates several things: apology, painful embarrassment, some additional pained embarrassment that serves to ironise and dilute the painful kind, a sense that she knows she will be forgiven or is already, a desire not to 'make a big deal.' " Then: "Forget about it, he says." Rooney precisely articulates everything that's going on below the surface; there's humor and insight here as well as the pleasure of getting to know two prickly, complicated people as they try to figure out who they are and who they want to become.

Pub Date: April 16, 2019

ISBN: 978-1-984-82217-8

Page Count: 288

Publisher: Hogarth

Review Posted Online: Feb. 17, 2019

Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 1, 2019

More by Sally Rooney

BEAUTIFUL WORLD, WHERE ARE YOU

by Sally Rooney

CONVERSATIONS WITH FRIENDS

More About This Book

Our Editor-in-Chief Surveys the Best of 2019 and Picks Some Favorites

PERSPECTIVES

Here Are Barack Obama’s Favorite Books From His 2019 Reading

SEEN & HEARD

Normal People TV-Series Teaser Released

BOOK TO SCREEN

THE MOST FUN WE EVER HAD

THE MOST FUN WE EVER HAD

by Claire Lombardo ‧ RELEASE DATE: June 25, 2019

Characters flip between bottomless self-regard and pitiless self-loathing while, as late as the second-to-last chapter, yet...

Four Chicago sisters anchor a sharp, sly family story of feminine guile and guilt.

Newcomer Lombardo brews all seven deadly sins into a fun and brimming tale of an unapologetically bougie couple and their unruly daughters. In the opening scene, Liza Sorenson, daughter No. 3, flirts with a groomsman at her sister’s wedding. “There’s four of you?” he asked. “What’s that like?” Her retort: “It’s a vast hormonal hellscape. A marathon of instability and hair products.” Thus begins a story bristling with a particular kind of female intel. When Wendy, the oldest, sets her sights on a mate, she “made sure she left her mark throughout his house—soy milk in the fridge, box of tampons under the sink, surreptitious spritzes of her Bulgari musk on the sheets.” Turbulent Wendy is the novel’s best character, exuding a delectable bratty-ness. The parents—Marilyn, all pluck and busy optimism, and David, a genial family doctor—strike their offspring as impossibly happy. Lombardo levels this vision by interspersing chapters of the Sorenson parents’ early lean times with chapters about their daughters’ wobbly forays into adulthood. The central story unfurls over a single event-choked year, begun by Wendy, who unlatches a closed adoption and springs on her family the boy her stuffy married sister, Violet, gave away 15 years earlier. (The sisters improbably kept David and Marilyn clueless with a phony study-abroad scheme.) Into this churn, Lombardo adds cancer, infidelity, a heart attack, another unplanned pregnancy, a stillbirth, and an office crush for David. Meanwhile, youngest daughter Grace perpetrates a whopper, and “every day the lie was growing like mold, furring her judgment.” The writing here is silky, if occasionally overwrought. Still, the deft touches—a neighborhood fundraiser for a Little Free Library, a Twilight character as erotic touchstone—delight. The class calibrations are divine even as the utter apolitical whiteness of the Sorenson world becomes hard to fathom.

Pub Date: June 25, 2019

ISBN: 978-0-385-54425-2

Page Count: 544

Publisher: Doubleday

Review Posted Online: March 3, 2019

Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15, 2019

LITERARY FICTION | FAMILY LIFE & FRIENDSHIP

Mantel, Woodson on Women’s Prize Longlist

  • Discover Books Fiction Thriller & Suspense Mystery & Detective Romance Science Fiction & Fantasy Nonfiction Biography & Memoir Teens & Young Adult Children's
  • News & Features Bestsellers Book Lists Profiles Perspectives Awards Seen & Heard Book to Screen Kirkus TV videos In the News
  • Kirkus Prize Winners & Finalists About the Kirkus Prize Kirkus Prize Judges
  • Magazine Current Issue All Issues Manage My Subscription Subscribe
  • Writers’ Center Hire a Professional Book Editor Get Your Book Reviewed Advertise Your Book Launch a Pro Connect Author Page Learn About The Book Industry
  • More Kirkus Diversity Collections Kirkus Pro Connect My Account/Login
  • About Kirkus History Our Team Contest FAQ Press Center Info For Publishers
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Reprints, Permission & Excerpting Policy

© Copyright 2024 Kirkus Media LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Go To Top

Popular in this Genre

Close Quickview

Hey there, book lover.

We’re glad you found a book that interests you!

Please select an existing bookshelf

Create a new bookshelf.

We can’t wait for you to join Kirkus!

Please sign up to continue.

It’s free and takes less than 10 seconds!

Already have an account? Log in.

Sign in with Google

Trouble signing in? Retrieve credentials.

Almost there!

  • Industry Professional

Welcome Back!

My Name is Red

Orhan pamuk, ask litcharts ai: the answer to your questions.

Elegant has been murdered, and his corpse lies undiscovered at the bottom of a well. Speaking from the afterlife, he hopes that his body is found soon and that the murderer is captured. Meanwhile, Black has returned to Istanbul after 12 years away. Before he left, Black fell in love with his cousin, Shekure , and he has now been summoned home by Shekure’s father (and Black’s uncle) Enishte . Enishte wants Black to work on a secret book commissioned by the Sultan and illustrated by the three master miniaturists, Butterfly , Stork , and Olive .

The murderer reflects on his difficulty coming to terms with the fact that he has taken someone’s life. He has started frequenting a coffeehouse where a storyteller entertains the audience by impersonating different characters; the murderer laughs at the storyteller’s impression of a dog, and he admits that he killed Elegant because Elegant was threatening to tell everyone about the secret book.

Enishte originally sent Black away after learning that he had fallen in love with Shekure, but he is now pleased with the way that Black has matured during his time in exile. He tells Black about a trip he took to Venice, during which he was astonished (and frightened) by the new realist style of European painting. Enishte introduces Black to Shekure’s six-year-old son Orhan , who then overhears Enishte telling Black about the death of Elegant, whom people suspect was murdered. As Black leaves Enishte’s house, Esther , a Jewish clothier, gives him a letter from Shekure. Riding away on his horse, Black catches a glimpse of Shekure at her window. Shekure admires Black’s handsomeness, but feels conflicted, as she is still technically married to a soldier who never returned from war. Shekure previously lived with her husband’s father and his brother, Hasan , but left when Hasan tried to rape her.

The next chapter is narrated by an illustration of a tree , who declares that it is lonely because it fell out of the book of which it was supposed to be a part. Meanwhile, Black goes to see Master Osman , the Head Illuminator, and he is given a tour of the Royal Workshop. Osman is suspicious of Black, as Enishte is Osman’s archrival. Black then makes individual visits to Butterfly, Stork, and Olive, who each tell Black three different parables about style and signature.

Black gives Esther a letter for Shekure, but before bringing it to Shekure, Esther shows it to Hasan, who writes his own letter. After receiving both letters, Shekure confesses that she is confused about whom to marry. Enishte goes to Elegant’s funeral, where Butterfly tells him that he believes Olive and Stork are behind Elegant’s death. The murderer admits that he put on a big show of grief at the funeral and that he does feel a genuine sense of torment about killing Elegant.

The storyteller’s next narrative is told from the perspective of a gold counterfeit coin , who argues that the people of Istanbul are all obsessed with money. Enishte explains to Black that the final illustration in the secret book will be a portrait of the Sultan, although Enishte is having trouble finishing it. The murderer sees Black leaving Enishte’s house and realizes that Black intends to marry Shekure, which fills the murderer with furious jealousy.

After Esther shows Hasan more letters between Black and Shekure, Hasan writes his own letter to Shekure, threatening to force her to return to his father’s house. Shekure and Black meet at a house that formerly belonged to a Jewish man who was hanged. They kiss and begin to have sex, but Shekure insists that they stop and she makes Black agree to a list of demands in preparation for their marriage.

While Shekure and Black are out, the murderer goes to Enishte’s house and they have a long conversation about art, religion, sin, and the secret book. Eventually, the murderer tells Enishte that it was he who murdered Elegant. They continue their discussion, but it becomes clear to both of them that the murderer intends to kill Enishte. The murderer smashes a Mongolian inkpot over Enishte’s head, and Enishte cries out in agony before dying. His soul is carried to the heavens in the palm of the Angel Azrael.

Shekure walks home in the snow , discovers Enishte’s dead body, and hides the body while pretending to her two sons that Enishte is merely sick. At the coffeehouse, the storyteller speaks from the perspective of the color red , reflecting on the impossibility of explaining color to someone who has never seen it.

In the morning, Shekure meets Black and makes a plan to legally authorize her widowhood so that they can marry. Black bribes an imam to issue the certificate of widowhood and arranges for the imam to officiate their marriage. The wedding takes place around Enishte’s body, with Shekure and Black managing to convince the imam and guests that Enishte is alive and providing his consent from his deathbed. That night, Hasan comes to Enishte’s house and threatens to force Shekure to come back to his father’s house. In the morning, Shekure tells the children that Enishte has just died; her eldest son, Shevket , doesn’t believe her, claiming that he knows Enishte died the previous night.

Black goes to the palace to bring news of Enishte’s death to the Sultan, who is deeply saddened. Black explains that the murderer stole the final illustration for the book, adding that Enishte believed that Elegant was murdered by one of the three master miniaturists and that Enishte’s and Elegant’s murderer is likely the same person.

Enishte is pleased by his funeral, which he witnesses from the afterlife. He explains that after dying he experienced a dazzling array of vivid colors, a collapse of time and space into a single plane, and a conversation in which Allah reassured him about his use of the European style, stating: “East and West belong to me.” After Enishte’s funeral, Esther visits Elegant’s widow, Kabilye , who shows her a drawing of horses that was found on Elegant’s dead body. Kabilye insists that Elegant did not create the drawing himself.

Black is summoned to the palace, where his head is put in a vice. However, just as the torture begins Master Osman interrupts and explains that the Sultan has given them three days in which to figure out who killed Enishte. Black and Osman discuss the particular characteristics of each of the miniaturists, and Osman states that he believes Stork is the murderer. One of the palace officials shows them the horse illustration found on Elegant’s dead body, and they resolve to hold a pretend horse-drawing competition in order to figure out which miniaturist drew the horses, and thus which one is the murderer.

Olive, Butterfly, and Stork each draw horses for the competition, and the murderer asks the reader if they were able to identify him through his drawing. He then describes going to the coffeehouse, where he tells two stories. As he is about to tell a third, he is cut off by the storyteller, who impersonates Satan and claims that evil and free will are important parts of the world and that Allah does not care about minor sins.

Having reached a dead end with the competition, Black goes to the palace, where Master Osman obtains the Sultan’s permission to look through the Royal Treasury for clues that will lead to the murderer. Black and Osman spend hours searching through the books in the treasury and having occasional conversations about the history and future of the miniaturist tradition. Eventually, Black falls asleep, and Master Osman happens upon the needle that Bihzad used both to paint and, eventually, to blind himself. Osman pierces his own eyes with the same needle, and his vision begins to slip away.

When Black is awake again, he and Osman discuss the identity of the murderer; Osman insists that it is Stork. Black goes home in a joyful mood, but he finds that Shekure and the boys are not there. He learns that they are at Hasan’s house and he brings a gang of men from the neighborhood to help him take Shekure back. After some confusion, Hasan’s father permits Shekure and the children to leave. At this moment, the Erzurumis descend on the coffeehouse; Black sends Shekure home and promises to join her soon.

At the coffeehouse, the storyteller tells of his desire to be a woman and he sings a poem about conflicted identity. When the Erzurumis raid the coffeehouse, they kill the storyteller, and Black and Butterfly go to Butterfly’s house. Black interrogates Butterfly and Butterfly pins him to the ground in an aggressive, erotic gesture. Butterfly says he believes Stork is the murderer, and he and Black set off for Stork’s house.

Once there, Stork tells them that Olive drew the horse illustration found on Enishte’s dead body. He adds that Olive will be at the abandoned dervish lodge, which is indeed where they find him. Olive denies drawing the horses. Stork and Black search for the book’s final illustration but find nothing. Olive begins to cry, and it is now clear to everyone present that he is the murderer. He suggests that the miniaturists must now kill Master Osman, and Black puts a knife to Olive’s throat, demanding to know the location of the final illustration. There is a scuffle during which the murderer is blinded. He confesses to both murders and tells the others that there is only once chance to escape the death of the miniaturist tradition—move to India, where the Sultan of Hindustan is gathering the best miniaturists for his royal workshop.

Olive attempts to kill Black but he misses, and then he runs away through the streets of Istanbul and encounters Hasan, who—mistaking Olive for one of Black’s allies—cuts off his head.

In the final chapter, Shekure tells of the fates of the characters after the main narrative ends. She explains that she told the story to Orhan and showed him the letters she exchanged with Hasan and Black, warning the reader that Orhan may not tell the exact truth but that this is in service of creating “a delightful and convincing story.”

The LitCharts.com logo.

book review my name is red

  • Kindle Store
  • Kindle eBooks
  • Arts & Photography

Audible Logo

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required .

Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.

Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.

QR code to download the Kindle App

Image Unavailable

My Name Is Red

  • To view this video download Flash Player

Follow the authors

Orhan Pamuk

My Name Is Red Kindle Edition

** ORDER NIGHTS OF PLAGUE, THE NEW NOVEL FROM ORHAN PAMUK ** Winner of the Nobel Prize for Literature Winner of the International IMPAC Dublin Award 'Wonderful' The Spectator 'Magnificent' Observer 'Sumptuous' New Yorker 'Unforgettable' Guardian My Name is Red is an unforgettable murder mystery, set amid the splendour of sixteenth century Istanbul, from the Nobel prizewinning author In the late 1590s, the Sultan secretly commissions a great book: a celebration of his life and his empire, to be illuminated by the best artists of the day - in the European manner. At a time of violent fundamentalism, however, this is a dangerous proposition. Even the illustrious circle of artists are not allowed to know for whom they are working. But when one of the miniaturists is murdered, their Master has to seek outside help. Did the dead painter fall victim to professional rivalry, romantic jealousy or religious terror? With the Sultan demanding an answer within three days, perhaps the clue lies somewhere in the half-finished pictures . . . Orhan Pamuk is one of the world's leading contemporary novelists and in My Name is Red, he fashioned an unforgettable tale of suspense, and an artful meditation on love and deception.

  • Print length 434 pages
  • Language English
  • Sticky notes On Kindle Scribe
  • Publisher Faber & Faber
  • Publication date August 5, 2011
  • File size 3000 KB
  • Page Flip Enabled
  • Word Wise Enabled
  • Enhanced typesetting Enabled
  • See all details

Customers who bought this item also bought

A House for Mr. Biswas: A Novel (Vintage International)

Editorial Reviews

From publishers weekly, from library journal, from booklist, from the inside flap, from the back cover, about the author, excerpt. © reprinted by permission. all rights reserved., from audiofile, product details.

  • ASIN ‏ : ‎ B005GYYXS0
  • Publisher ‏ : ‎ Faber & Faber; Open Market - Airside ed edition (August 5, 2011)
  • Publication date ‏ : ‎ August 5, 2011
  • Language ‏ : ‎ English
  • File size ‏ : ‎ 3000 KB
  • Text-to-Speech ‏ : ‎ Enabled
  • Screen Reader ‏ : ‎ Supported
  • Enhanced typesetting ‏ : ‎ Enabled
  • X-Ray ‏ : ‎ Not Enabled
  • Word Wise ‏ : ‎ Enabled
  • Sticky notes ‏ : ‎ On Kindle Scribe
  • Print length ‏ : ‎ 434 pages
  • Page numbers source ISBN ‏ : ‎ 0375706852
  • #107 in Commercial Illustration
  • #175 in History of Turkey & the Ottoman empire
  • #809 in Calligraphy Guides

About the authors

Orhan pamuk.

Orhan Pamuk, described as 'one of the freshest, most original voices in contemporary fiction' (Independent on Sunday), is the author of many books, including The White Castle, The Black Book and The New Life. In 2003 he won the International IMPAC Award for My Name is Red, and in 2004 Faber published the translation of his novel Snow, which The Times described as 'a novel of profound relevance to the present moment'. His most recent book was Istanbul, described by Jan Morris as 'irresistibly seductive'. He was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature in 2006. He lives in Istanbul.

Photo by David Shankbone (Orhan Pamuk discusses his new book about love) [CC BY 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons.

Erdağ M. Göknar

Erdağ Göknar is Associate Professor of Turkish and Middle East Studies at Duke University and an award-winning translator. His translation of Orhan Pamuk's historical novel MY NAME IS RED won the International Dublin Literary Award (2003), marking Pamuk's emergence as an author of world literature and contributing to his selection as Nobel laureate (2006). The best selling novel was reissued in 2010 as part of the Everyman's Library Contemporary Classics series. Göknar is also the translator of A.H. Tanpınar's iconic novel of Istanbul, A MIND AT PEACE, and Atiq Rahimi's anti-war novella set in Afghanistan, EARTH AND ASHES. His critical literary study, ORHAN PAMUK, SECULARISM, AND BLASPHEMY: THE POLITICS OF THE TURKISH NOVEL (Routledge 2013), argues that the productive tension between Turkish Islam and state secularism give Pamuk's work currency as world literature. Göknar's poetry collection, NOMADOLOGIES (Turtle Point 2017), engages themes of Turkish-American diaspora.

Customer reviews

Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.

To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.

  • Sort reviews by Top reviews Most recent Top reviews

Top reviews from the United States

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. please try again later..

book review my name is red

Top reviews from other countries

book review my name is red

Report an issue

  • Amazon Newsletter
  • About Amazon
  • Accessibility
  • Sustainability
  • Press Center
  • Investor Relations
  • Amazon Devices
  • Amazon Science
  • Sell on Amazon
  • Sell apps on Amazon
  • Supply to Amazon
  • Protect & Build Your Brand
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Become a Delivery Driver
  • Start a Package Delivery Business
  • Advertise Your Products
  • Self-Publish with Us
  • Become an Amazon Hub Partner
  • › See More Ways to Make Money
  • Amazon Visa
  • Amazon Store Card
  • Amazon Secured Card
  • Amazon Business Card
  • Shop with Points
  • Credit Card Marketplace
  • Reload Your Balance
  • Amazon Currency Converter
  • Your Account
  • Your Orders
  • Shipping Rates & Policies
  • Amazon Prime
  • Returns & Replacements
  • Manage Your Content and Devices
  • Recalls and Product Safety Alerts
  • Conditions of Use
  • Privacy Notice
  • Consumer Health Data Privacy Disclosure
  • Your Ads Privacy Choices

WTOP News

WTOP Book Report: In ‘My Name Was Eden’ one twin vanished in the womb, while the other remained … until now

Terik King | [email protected]

May 26, 2024, 10:00 PM

  • Share This:
  • share on facebook
  • share on threads
  • share on linkedin
  • share on email

This story was written as part of the WTOP Book Report series written by Terik King.  Read more of that coverage .

book review my name is red

In her riveting debut novel, My Name Was Eden (HarperCollins) , UK-based author Eleanor Barker-White channels the profundity of life into art by telling the tale of a mother named Lucy, and her struggle after her teenage daughter, Eden, survives a near-fatal drowning incident and returns claiming to be Eli, the name reserved for Eden’s unborn twin who vanished during pregnancy.

As Barker-White told the WTOP Book Report, the seed of the story was rooted in her own experience with the real-life phenomenon of vanishing twin syndrome .

“When I was pregnant with my son, Ethan, he was a twin,” Barker-White explained. “At the first scan, there were two hearts beating, but at the next scan, about eight weeks later, they said one had vanished. I had to get my head around that, and I started wondering where the twin had gone … the fact that it had been absorbed by my surviving twin was just weird.”

But then, she continued, “I started (thinking about) what the effects could be if this twin came back. That was where the seed of it came from.”

When Eden emerges from the incident without a scratch, she soon begins asserting that her name is Eli — her unborn fraternal twin brother — unsettling her mother with a steady demeanor and strange new smile. Lucy’s husband, James, and their doctor dismiss her concerns, but Lucy remains convinced that the daughter she knew is gone.

The story’s emotional core centers around the complexities of the parent-child relationship and the impact of unresolved trauma.

“Lucy always hankered after the lost twin, especially because she never really had much of a relationship with Eden,” Barker-White noted.

The drowning incident serves as the catalyst for exposing deeper fissures in Lucy and James’ marriage, forcing them to confront past traumas and the strain on their relationship.

“They were butting heads from the beginning,” said Barker-White, “(James) just wanted his little girl back. But the mum quite enjoyed the fact that she had a second chance to become closer to her child.”

Asked if she and her husband experienced similar marital turbulence when they experienced vanishing twin syndrome personally, Barker-White laughed, “Yeah … obviously not to the same extent, because the twin never came back. (But) yes, it did expose differences between us and the way we dealt with things.”

Barker-White also drew from her professional background in family support work and family law courts.

“ I’ve gathered a lot of information about families and different types of family dynamics,” she said. “When a child comes along, it changes the dynamic, and I wanted to explore that.”

In addition to Lucy, My Name Was Eden is told from the additional perspective of Charlie, Eden’s teenage best friend, “so that she could expose how different Eli is than Eden was previously.”

The difference in perspectives between narrators brings the reader to a tense uncertainty: Is any of this even happening? Is this the stunt of a troubled teenager? Or is this all occurring inside the mind of a troubled and traumatized mother?

“There are two ways of looking at it, effectively,” Barker-White teased. “So I wanted it to be a little ambiguous; a bit like when you look at a piece of art in a gallery, (and) you might see something, and then somebody else might come along and see the piece differently.”

Barker-White said My Name Was Eden has resonated with early readers, including those with personal connections to twins. “I’ve had a lot of people with twins … it’s as though they’re in this club … and they really, really enjoy it.” said Barker-White.

“Twins are often seen as something out of the ordinary, a blessing, so yeah it’s all been really great feedback which I’m very grateful for.”

Get breaking news and daily headlines delivered to your email inbox by signing up here .

© 2024 WTOP. All Rights Reserved. This website is not intended for users located within the European Economic Area.

Terik King is an Associate Producer for WTOP. Before joining WTOP in 2022 he held roles producing podcasts, unscripted television and content for MTV, the NFL and independent documentary production companies.

Related News

WTOP Book Report: How ‘Jazzmen’ Ellington, Basie and Armstrong moved America forward on racial justice

WTOP Book Report: How ‘Jazzmen’ Ellington, Basie and Armstrong moved America forward on racial justice

WTOP Book Report: Reporter-turned-author Christina Estes unveils debut mystery novel ‘Off the Air’

WTOP Book Report: Reporter-turned-author Christina Estes unveils debut mystery novel ‘Off the Air’

WTOP Book Report: Writing for ‘The Girls’: TV trailblazer Stan Zimmerman discusses iconic career

WTOP Book Report: Writing for ‘The Girls’: TV trailblazer Stan Zimmerman discusses iconic career

Recommended.

3 critically hurt, including teen girl, after shooting sends barrage of bullets into Prince George's Co. residence

3 critically hurt, including teen girl, after shooting sends barrage of bullets into Prince George's Co. residence

Maryland hopes to recruit young dentists to workforce shortage areas

Maryland hopes to recruit young dentists to workforce shortage areas

Maryland wants your ideas on how to rebuild the Francis Scott Key Bridge

Maryland wants your ideas on how to rebuild the Francis Scott Key Bridge

Related categories:.

book review my name is red

an image, when javascript is unavailable

site categories

‘cocomelon’ and ‘blippi’ producer moonbug entertainment ups courtney holt to managing director, americas, as andy yeatman exits, skydance sweetens offer for paramount global.

By Jill Goldsmith , Anthony D'Alessandro

Shari Redstone and David Ellison

David Ellison ‘s Skydance has sweetened its offer to acquire Paramount Global, Deadline has learned, in an attempt to make it more palatable to the company’s Class B stockholders after they trashed the outlines of a previous deal and threatened to sue.

Ellison’s original offer was to buy out Par’s controlling shareholder Shari Redstone for a significant premium, resulting in a windfall for her, and then merge Skydance into Paramount keeping the combined company public. Stockholders wanted to be bought out at a premium as well.

Related Stories

book review my name is red

Chris Hemsworth In Talks To Star In Paramount's Transformers/G.I. Joe Crossover Movie

David Zaslav

David Zaslav Is Talking M&A Again As WBD Pays Down Debt, Expands Max Globally

The parameters of the revised bid couldn’t be learned immediately but Deadline understands that Skydance is putting more money in and restructuring the deal to make it more palatable to the Class B folks.

As the Skydance exclusive talks ended with no deal, Sony jumped in for a $26 billion cash bid with private equity giant Apollo, which was later downsized in some fashion as Sony signed a non-disclosure agreement with Par about two weeks ago that would let SPE access Par’s books and talks to start in earnest. Those conversations were not exclusive, however, and Skydance remained very much in the mix, continuing to talk with Par as well.

The issue for Sony is not shareholders but regulators. Foreign ownership rules likely prevent Sony from owning CBS broadcast assets, which is probably why its offer became more targeted. But it might not be a cakewalk to merge two major studios either. Skydance is safer, more certain on the regulatory front and wouldn’t require a prolonged review amid possible opposition that can drag a deal out and sometimes end without one.

Par hasn’t said whether the three had continued to serve actively on the committee after their pending departures were announced, or what the committee composition is now or will be after the meeting where shareholders vote for directors among other issues on the agenda and can ask questions. There’s speculation the committee maybe needed to wrap up and present options by the annual meeting but that may not be the case. The committee in any case is just there for a recommendation, with Redstone the decider and, some feel, a wildcard.

Says one source with knowledge of the dealings, “At the end of the day, whatever the committee recommends to Shari, it’s up to her to decide. A deal’s not a deal without her.”

Hollywood insiders favor a Skydance deal over a Sony/Apollo takeover of Paramount Global. The reduction of a major studio strikes fear throughout the exhibition sector that fewer event films would exist in the long run, the sector currently weathering the aftermath of Covid, two strikes and a Disney-Fox merger which has reduced the supply of movies at multiplexes.

Skydance’s last offer included a sweetened $3 billion cash injection — up by at least $1 billion contemplated previously. What’s key as a priority is Paramount holding enough cash on its balance sheet for an investment grade status with big ratings agencies. It included some premium sweetener for a percentage of non-voting Class B shares. Redstone would take an unspecified haircut compared with the initial offer terms where Skydance had proposed buying out Redstone’s controlling Class A voting shares and some other assets for about $2 billion. 

Paramount’s all stock acquisition of Skydance, planned as a second step in the transaction, valued the Ellison studio at about $5 billion, which also irked investors who called it too high and said it would dilute their holdings. It’s not clear if that part of the offer has changed.

Par shares are up 2% to about $12.

Must Read Stories

Sony shutters tristar television; jennifer turner & nicole norwood to depart.

book review my name is red

‘Garfield’ Has Upper Paw Over ‘Furiosa’ With $12M+ Second Weekend

Studio bosses on death of peak tv, canceled shows, hollywood contraction & more, jennifer lopez axes entire summer tour months after canceling several dates.

Subscribe to Deadline Breaking News Alerts and keep your inbox happy.

Read More About:

Deadline is a part of Penske Media Corporation. © 2024 Deadline Hollywood, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Quantcast

book review my name is red

What’s new on Hulu in June 2024 and what’s leaving soon

F X is going to make this summer a great time to be a  Hulu subscriber, especially in June. The only bad news is that one of the best shows on TV, The Bear , won’t be arriving until near the end of the month. In the meantime, FX and Hulu are premiering the new drama Clipped , which chronicles the downfall of Los Angeles Clippers owner Donald Sterling, on June 4.

As for the new movies that are kicking off the month, there are some surprising additions including The Batman and Joker , as well as the return of Fight Club , Office Space , and the very un-Disney-like Borat .

Keep reading for our roundup of everything coming to Hulu in June 2024 and what’s leaving at the end of the month. Our picks for June are in bold.

Since you’re a Hulu fan, be sure to check out the Disney Bundle , which will get you Disney+, ESPN+, and a basic Hulu subscription for just $14 a month. You’re basically getting three streaming services for the price of two — it’s tough to turn that down. And if you want an even better deal on live TV, you’ll need to make a decision between YouTube TV and Hulu With Live TV .

Need more suggestions?

  • What’s new on Netflix
  • What’s new on Max
  • What’s new on Amazon Prime
  • What’s new on Disney+
  • What’s new on Peacock

Everything new on Hulu in June

  • Ace of Cakes: Complete Season 9
  • Alaskan Bush People: Complete Seasons 5-7
  • The Amazing Race: Complete Seasons 18-21
  • Bahamas Life: Complete Season 4
  • Boruto: Naruto Next Generations
  • Caribbean Life: Complete Season 14
  • Chopped: Complete Seasons 51 and 54
  • Hawaii Life: Complete Season 1
  • House Hunters International: Complete Season 139
  • House Hunters: Complete Season 171
  • Island Life: Complete Season 17
  • Maine Cabin Masters: Complete Season 7
  • Survivor: Compelete Seasons 9-10, 26-27
  • Welcome to Plathville: Complete Seasons 2-3
  • About Last Night (1986)
  • Anchorman: The Legend Of Ron Burgundy
  • Anchorman 2: The Legend Continues
  • Betsy’s Wedding
  • Blades Of Glory
  • Borat: Cultural Learnings Of America For Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan
  • Boys Don’t Cry
  • Brown Sugar
  • Coyote Ugly
  • The Day After Tomorrow
  • Death on the Nile (2022)
  • Eight Millimeter
  • Fast & Furious Presents: Hobbs & Shaw
  • Ferris Bueller’s Day Off
  • Freddy Got Fingered
  • Fresh Horses
  • The Girl Next Door
  • Hide and Seek
  • Independence Day
  • Jazz Fest: A New Orleans Story
  • Kill Your Darlings
  • Little Black Book
  • Lord of War
  • The Missing
  • Money Monster
  • The New Guy
  • Office Space
  • Over The Hedge
  • Prayers for Bobby
  • Saw: The Final Chapter
  • Silent Hill
  • Slums Of Beverly Hills
  • St. Elmo’s Fire
  • Van Helsing
  • Weird Science
  • Working Girl
  • World Eats: Bread — Complete Season 1
  • Bullet Train
  • Cameron Esposito: Marriage Material
  • Eddie Izzard: Dress to Kill
  • Eddie Izzard: Wunderbar
  • Gina Yashere: Skinny Bitch
  • Jinkx Monsoon: Red Head Redemption
  • Monét X Change: Fist of Glory
  • Peppermint: So-Sigh-Ety Effects
  • Todd Glass: Talks About Stuff
  • FX’s Clipped: Two-Episode Series Premiere
  • Erased: WWII Heroes of Color: Complete Docuseries
  • Name That Tune: Season 4 Premiere
  • The Real Red Tails: Special Premiere
  • An Audience With Kylie: Special
  • Jungle Bunch: Operation Meltdown
  • Perfect Days
  • Becoming Karl Lagerfeld: Complete Limited Series
  • Queenie: Complete Season 1
  • Beautiful Wedding
  • Step Up 2 The Streets
  • What Comes Around
  • Love Island U.K.: Season 11 Premiere
  • Protecting Paradise: The Story of Niue
  • Candis Cayne’s Secret Garden: Complete Season 1
  • OUT 100: 2021, 2022, 2023 Specials
  • 2024 LA Pride Parade: Livestream
  • Restaurant Startup: Complete Series
  • Rich Kids of Beverly Hills: Complete Series
  • WAGS: Complete Series
  • WAGS Atlanta: Complete Series
  • WAGS Miami: Complete Series
  • Wreck: Complete Season 2
  • GO! GO! Loser Ranger!: Series Premiere
  • iHeart Radio & P&G “Can’t Cancel Pride” Special: Livestream
  • From Tomorrow: Complete Season 1
  • BRATS: Documentary Premiere
  • Pirates: Truth Behind Legends
  • To Kill a Stepfather
  • Trapped in the Farmhouse
  • Blood Free: Complete Season 1
  • Chewing Gum: Complete Series
  • Jeff Dunham: Unhinged In Hollywood
  • Joel McHale: Live from Pyongyang
  • Lavell Crawford: Home for the Holidays
  • Lavell Crawford: New LookSame Funny (Extended Edition)
  • Margaret Cho – PsyCHO
  • Mike Birbiglia: What I Should Have Said Was Nothing
  • Mike Birbiglia: My Girlfriend’s Boyfriend
  • Thee Lavell Crawford
  • Tom Segura: Completely Normal
  • Whitney Cummings: Money Shot
  • I Kissed a Boy: Complete Season 1
  • In the Fade
  • Cult Massacre: One Day in Jonestown: Complete Limited Series
  • Mission: Yozakura Family: Series Premiere 
  • Clotilda: The Return Home
  • Cesar Millan: Better Human, Better Dog: Complete Season 4
  • To Catch a Smuggler: Complete Season 7
  • Wicked Tuna: Complete Season 13
  • Perfect Wife: The Mysterious Disappearance of Sherri Papini: Complete Documentary Series
  • Shoresy: Complete Season 3
  • Prey (2024)
  • Breakin’ On the One: Documentary Film Premiere
  • The Invitation (2022)
  • Diane von Furstenberg: Woman in Charge: Documentary Premiere
  • Kokdu: Season of Deity Season 1 
  • A Love Song
  • FX’s The Bear: Complete Season 3
  • Amelia’s Children

What’s leaving Hulu in June 2024

  • Just Friends
  • The Secret Garden
  • The Dog Knight
  • The Free Fall
  • The Burning Plain
  • Europa Report
  • The Good Doctor
  • I Melt With You
  • World’s Greatest Dad
  • The Wrecking Crew
  • The Accursed
  • Between Me and My Mind
  • Queens of Pain
  • A Good Day To Die Hard
  • The Bounty Hunter
  • The Chronicles of Riddick
  • Come See The Paradise
  • Die Hard With A Vengeance
  • Live Free Or Die Hard
  • The Rundown
  • Tyler Perry’s Madea’s Family Reunion

What’s new on Hulu in June 2024 and what’s leaving soon

  • Share full article

Advertisement

Supported by

Caleb Carr, Author of Dark Histories, Dies at 68

His own dark history prompted him to write about and investigate the roots of violence, notably in his best-selling novel “The Alienist.”

A photo of a man in a blazer, sweater vest, shirt and tie. He has a gray beard, shoulder-length hair and rimless glasses, and sits on a deck in a chair draped in a fur. He holds a sword on his shoulder and looks off camera.

By Penelope Green

Caleb Carr, a military historian and author whose experience of childhood abuse drove him to explore the roots of violence — most famously in his 1994 best seller, “The Alienist,” a period thriller about the hunt for a serial killer in 19th-century Manhattan — died on Thursday at his home in Cherry Plain, N.Y. He was 68.

The cause was cancer, his brother Ethan Carr said.

Mr. Carr was 39 when he published “The Alienist,” an atmospheric detective story about a child psychiatrist — or an alienist, as those who studied the mind were called in the 1890s — who investigates the murders of young male prostitutes by using forensic psychiatry, which was an unorthodox method at the time.

Mr. Carr had first pitched the book as nonfiction; it wasn’t, but it read that way because of the exhaustive research he did into the period. He rendered the dank horrors of Manhattan’s tenement life, its sadistic gangs and the seedy brothels that were peddling children, as well as the city’s lush hubs of power, like Delmonico’s restaurant. And he peopled his novel with historical figures like Theodore Roosevelt, who was New York’s reforming police commissioner before his years in the White House. Even Jacob Riis had a cameo.

Up to that point, Mr. Carr had been writing, with modest success, on military matters. He had contributed articles to The Quarterly Journal of Military History, and he had written, with James Chace, a book about national security and, on his own, a well-received biography of an American soldier of fortune who became a Chinese military hero in the mid-19th century.

Mr. Carr had also been a regular contributor to the letters page of The New York Times; he notably once chastised Henry Kissinger for what Mr. Carr characterized as his outdated theories of international diplomacy. He was 19 at the time.

“The Alienist” was an immediate hit and earned glowing reviews. Even before it was published, the movie rights were snapped up by the producer Scott Rudin for half a million dollars. (The paperback rights sold for more than a million.)

“You can practically hear the clip-clop of horses’ hooves echoing down old Broadway,” Christopher Lehmann-Haupt wrote in his review in The Times . “You can taste the good food at Delmonico’s. You can smell the fear in the air.”

Magazine writers were captivated by Mr. Carr’s downtown cool — he lived on the Lower East Side of Manhattan, had been in a local punk band, wore black high-top sneakers and had shoulder-length hair — and by his literary provenance. His father was Lucien Carr, a journalist who was muse to and best friends with Beat royalty: the writers Jack Kerouac, William S. Burroughs and Allen Ginsberg. Beautiful and charismatic as a young man, “Lou was the glue,” Ginsberg once said, that held the group together.

The elder Mr. Carr was also an alcoholic, and Caleb grew up in bohemian chaos. The Carr household was the scene of drunken revelries, and much worse. Mr. Carr raged at his wife and three sons. But he directed his most terrifying outbursts at Caleb, his middle child, whom he singled out for physical abuse.

Caleb’s parents divorced when he was 8. But the beatings continued for years.

“There’s no question that I have a lifelong fascination with violence,” Caleb Carr told Stephen Dubner of New York magazine in 1994 , just before “The Alienist” was published, explaining not just the engine for the book but why he was drawn to military history. “Part of it was a desire to find violence that was, in the first place, directed toward some purposeful end, and second, governed by a definable ethical code. And I think it’s fairly obvious why I would want to do that.”

Lucien Carr had also been abused. Growing up in St. Louis, he was sexually molested by his Boy Scout master, a man named David Kammerer who followed him to the East Coast, where Lucien entered Columbia University and met Kerouac, Ginsberg and Burroughs. One drunken night in 1944, Mr. Carr killed his longtime predator in Riverside Park, stabbing him with his Boy Scout knife and rolling him into the Hudson River. Kerouac helped him dispose of the knife. Lucien turned himself in the next day and served two years for manslaughter in a reformatory.

The killing was a cause célèbre, and became a kind of origin story for the history of the Beats . Kerouac and Burroughs rendered it in purple prose in a novel they archly titled “And the Hippos Were Boiled in Their Tanks,” which was rejected by publishers and then mired in legalities before finally being published in 2008, when all the principals were dead. (It was panned by Michiko Kakutani in The Times.) In 2013, it was the subject of a film, “Kill Your Darlings,” starring Daniel Radcliffe as Allen Ginsberg.

Caleb Carr and his family found “Kill Your Darlings” more than flawed, taking issue with the film’s thesis that Lucien was a conflicted gay man in a repressive society — and that Kammerer was the victim and their relationship was consensual.

“My father fit perfectly ‘the cycle of abuse,’” Mr. Carr told an interviewer at the time . “Of all the terrible things that Kammerer did, perhaps the worst was to teach him this, to teach him that the most fundamental way to form bonds was through abuse.”

He added: “When I confronted him many years later about his extreme violence toward me, after I had entered therapy, he at length asked (after denying that such violence had occurred for as long as he could, then conceding it), ‘Doesn’t that mean that there’s a special bond between us?’ And I remember that my blood had never run quite that cold.”

Caleb Carr was born on Aug. 2, 1955, in Manhattan. His father, after being released from the reformatory, worked as a reporter and editor for United Press International, where he met Francesca von Hartz, a reporter. They married in 1952 and had three sons, Simon, Caleb and Ethan. After they divorced a decade later, Ms. von Hartz married John Speicher, an editor and novelist with three daughters. The couple and their six children moved to a loft on East 14th Street, a dangerous area in the late 1960s and ’70s. It was another chaotic household overseen by alcoholics, and the children often referred to themselves as “the dark Brady Bunch.”

Caleb attended Friends Seminary, a Quaker school in the East Village, where his interest in military history made him an outlier and a misfit. His high school transcript described him as “socially undesirable.” After graduating, he attended Kenyon College in Ohio and then New York University, where he earned a bachelor’s degree and studied military and diplomatic history.

In 1997, Mr. Carr published “The Angel of Darkness,” a sequel to “The Alienist.” It featured many of the same characters, who reunite to investigate the case of a missing child. It, too, was a best seller, “as winning a historical thriller” as its predecessor, The Times’s Mr. Lehmann-Haupt wrote .

Mr. Carr was the author of 11 books, including “The Italian Secretary” (2005), a Sherlock Holmes mystery commissioned by the estate of Arthur Conan Doyle; “Surrender, New York” (2016), a well-reviewed contemporary crime procedural that nonetheless sold poorly; and “Lessons of Terror: A History of Warfare Against Civilians” (2002), which he wrote in the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks.

Even in those pre-Twitter days, “Lessons of Terror” caused an internet ruckus. It was at once vociferously praised and bashed — and became a best seller, to boot — and Mr. Carr derided his critics on Amazon. Many challenged his contention that some “conventional” warfare — like General Sherman’s barbarism during the Civil War and Israel’s behavior toward the Palestinians — was equivalent to terrorism, a thesis that annoyed military historians , as well as The Times’s Ms. Kakutani .

What propelled Mr. Carr in all his work was the origins of violence, the mysteries of nature and nurture. In his own life, he was determined to end the cycle of his family’s dark legacy by not having children. That choice restricted his romantic life, and as he got older, he grew more solitary. When he bought 1,400 acres in Rensselaer County, N.Y., in 2000, and built himself a house near a ridge called Misery Mountain, he became even more so.

“I have a grim outlook on the world, and in particular on humanity,” he told Joyce Wadler of The Times in 2005 . “I spent years denying it, but I am very misanthropic. And I live alone on a mountain for a reason.”

His last book, published in April, was “My Beloved Monster: Masha, the Half-Wild Rescue Cat Who Rescued Me.” It’s both a memoir of his time there and a love story to the creature who was his most constant and sustaining companion during the last decades of his life.

“But how could you live for such a long time,” he said friends asked him, “alone on a mountain with just a cat?” He took umbrage at the phrase “just a cat.”

“It needs to be understood that, for Masha, I was always enough,” he wrote. “How I lived, what I chose to do, my very nature — all were good enough for her.”

Masha, like her human roommate, had suffered physical abuse at some point, and as Mr. Carr and his companion aged, their early horrors had devastating physical repercussions. Mr. Carr’s beatings had created scar tissue in his organs that led to other serious ailments. They were each diagnosed with cancer, but Masha died first.

In addition to his brother Ethan, Mr. Carr is survived by another brother, Simon; his stepsisters, Hilda, Jennifer and Christine Speicher; and his mother, now known as Francesca Cote. Lucien Carr died in 2005.

Despite the early hoopla, “The Alienist” never made it to the big screen. Producers wanted to turn it into a love story or otherwise alter Mr. Carr’s creation. But after decades of fits and starts, i t found a home on television , and in 2018 it was seen as a 10-episode mini-series on TNT. James Poniewozik of The Times called it “lush, moody, a bit stiff.” But it was mostly a success, reaching 50 million viewers and earning six Emmy Award nominations. (It won one, for special visual effects.)

“If I had known that nothing would have come out of this book other than the advance,” Mr. Carr said in 1994 as “The Alienist” was poised for publication, “I still would have written it exactly the same. But if you were to ask me to trade this book, this whole career and have my childhood be different, I probably would.”

An earlier version of this obituary misstated part of the name of the hamlet in New York State where Mr. Carr lived. It is Cherry Plain, not Cherry Plains.

How we handle corrections

Penelope Green is a Times reporter on the Obituaries desk. More about Penelope Green

COMMENTS

  1. My Name Is Red by Orhan Pamuk

    Orhan Pamuk, Erdağ M. Göknar (Translator) 3.87. 56,794 ratings5,240 reviews. At once a fiendishly devious mystery, a beguiling love story, and a brilliant symposium on the power of art, My Name Is Red is a transporting tale set amid the splendor and religious intrigue of sixteenth-century Istanbul, from one of the most prominent contemporary ...

  2. MY NAME IS RED

    There's a simplicity, a directness, a poignancy in the story that gives it a singular power, difficult to define. Steinbeck is a genius and an original. Share your opinion of this book. Acclaimed Turkish writer Pamuk (The New Life, 1997, etc.) investigates two brutal murders—and offers a whimsical but provocative exploration of the nature of ...

  3. Review: My Name is Red by Orhan Pamuk

    Firstly, My Name is Red is anintriguing murder-mystery that plays with the reader, challenging them to identify the murderer before they reach the end. There are some clues as to the identity of the murderer scattered about in the narrative as we read about secrets that harbour the four great miniaturists - "Stork", "Olive ...

  4. Book Review: My Name Is Red by Orhan Pamuk

    My Name is Red reads like a philosophical mystery, except it's only about art philosophy. It's a story about a murder among a group of miniaturists (which are basically artists), and it is set in the Ottoman Empire. The book itself was originally written in Turkish. The idea is that they are working on book of illustrations that reflects a ...

  5. My Name Is Red

    My Name Is Red (Turkish: Benim Adım Kırmızı) is a 1998 Turkish novel by writer Orhan Pamuk translated into English by Erdağ Göknar in 2001. The novel, concerning miniaturists in the Ottoman Empire of 1591, established Pamuk's international reputation and contributed to his reception of the Nobel Prize in Literature in 2006.. The book has been translated into more than 60 languages since ...

  6. Amazon.com: Customer reviews: My Name Is Red: A Novel

    A beautiful tale, told in a captivating way and wrapped around a good old-fashioned murder mystery, "My Name is Red" is easy to rate as a 5-star book. The many layers and textures of this book captivate the reader's senses, and the complex themes and messages engage the mind. Pamuk truly has delivered a delightful reading experience.

  7. Book Reviews: My Name Is Red, by Orhan Pamuk and Erdag ...

    My Name Is Red. Orhan Pamuk and Erdag Gokna | 3.93 | 44,378 ratings and reviews. Ranked #2 in Turkey, Ranked #3 in Turkish — see more rankings. At once a fiendishly devious mystery, a beguiling love story, and a brilliant symposium on the power of art, My Name Is Red is a transporting tale set amid the splendor and religious intrigue of ...

  8. My Name Is Red

    The Nobel Prize winner and one of today's most prominent contemporary Turkish writers delivers a novel that is a fiendishly devious mystery, a beguiling love story, a brilliant symposium on the power of art, and a "modern classic … rich and essential" (Los Angeles Times Book Review)—set amid the splendor and religious intrigue of sixteenth-century Istanbul.The Sultan has commissioned a ...

  9. Book Marks reviews of My Name is Red by Orhan Pamuk, trans. by Erda

    My Name Is Red is not just a novel of ideas. Eastern or Western, good or bad, ideas precipitate once they sink to human level, unleashing passions and violence. Red is chockful of sublimity and sin. The story is told by each of a dozen characters, and now and then by a dog, a tree, a gold coin, several querulous corpses and the color crimson ('My Name Is Red').

  10. My Name is Red (Orhan Pamuk)

    As a mystery and a reworked folktale, My Name is Red has some surprising twists and turns, powering a readily engaging plot; as a historical novel, its setting in late sixteenth century Istanbul is convincingly detailed; and as a novel it offers some memorable characters and complex relationships. But what is most notable about My Name is Red ...

  11. Heresies of the Paintbrush

    MY NAME IS RED. By Orhan Pamuk. Translated by Erdag M. Goknor. 417 pp. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. $25.95. Time's deletions, like a computer's, are not really deleted. A technician can restore what ...

  12. Review: My Name Is Red by Orhan Pamuk

    Part fantasy and part philosophical puzzle, My Name Is Red is a kaleidoscope journey into the intersection of art, religion, love, sex, and power. There are scenes in this book that don't require outside knowledge to appreciate. The story is told from a rotating set of perspectives that includes a corpse, dog, gold coin, and various ...

  13. My Name Is Red

    About My Name Is Red. The Nobel Prize winner and one of today's most prominent contemporary Turkish writers delivers a novel that is a fiendishly devious mystery, a beguiling love story, a brilliant symposium on the power of art, and a "modern classic … rich and essential" (Los Angeles Times Book Review)—set amid the splendor and religious intrigue of sixteenth-century Istanbul.

  14. Analysis of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red

    Analysis of Orhan Pamuk's My Name is Red By NASRULLAH MAMBROL on August 2, 2023. My Name Is Red, the recipient of the International Impac Dublin Literary Award in 2003, is perhaps the most celebrated book by the Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk (1952- ), who won the Nobel Prize in literature in 2006.The novel, which is superficially a murder mystery, details the artistic and philosophical ...

  15. 'My Name Is Red'

    By Orhan Pamuk. Sept. 2, 2001. I am nothing but a corpse now, a body at the bottom of a well. Although I drew my last breath long ago and my heart has stopped beating, no one, apart from that vile ...

  16. My Name is Red

    The complete review 's Review : My Name is Red is a novel presented in many voices and from many perspectives. The short chapters are narrated by more than a dozen different characters; most are human, but they also include a dog, a horse, a tree, and a coin. The novel begins dramatically: the first voice is that of a dead person, the just ...

  17. MY NAME IS RED by Orhan Pamuk ★★★★

    Translated from Turkish, My Name is Red doesn't always have the same kind of unity and coherence that a novel originally written in English might have. Moreover, Pamuk has very little time for dialogue. Most of the book is either description or introspection from the narrator to the reader. My Name is Red reminds me of a stage play.

  18. MY NAME IS RED

    Acclaimed Turkish writer Pamuk (The New Life, 1997, etc.) investigates two brutal murders—and offers a whimsical but provocative exploration of the nature of art in an Islamic society.My Name is Red speaks in many voices, some more predominant than others. A dog, a tree, and a horse as well as Death, Satan, and a corpse all make eloquent contributions to the narrative, but center stage are ...

  19. My Name Is Red: Written and Introduced by Orhan Pamuk (Everyman's

    His latest effort My Name is Red is a magnificent historical mystery, which manages to be a thrilling page-turner as well as a dense novel of ideas. The book is set in Istanbul in 1591. The Ottoman Empire is a major superpower, perhaps the most powerful in the world, and the sultan has commissioned a new book of paintings.

  20. My Name is Red Study Guide

    At the time My Name is Red takes place in 1591, the leader of the Ottoman Empire was Sultan Murat III, who is a character in the novel. Murat was a particularly enthusiastic patron of miniature painting, and he commissioned several books to be painted by painters employed by the Ottoman court. When Murat died in 1595, he was succeeded by his ...

  21. My Name is Red

    My Name is Red. From one of the most important and acclaimed writers at work today, a thrilling new novel--part murder mystery, part love story--set amid the perils of religious repression in sixteenth-century Istanbul. When the Sultan commissions a great book to celebrate his royal self and his extensive dominion, he directs Enishte Effendi to ...

  22. My Name is Red by Orhan Pamuk Plot Summary

    My Name is Red Summary. Next. Chapter 1. Elegant has been murdered, and his corpse lies undiscovered at the bottom of a well. Speaking from the afterlife, he hopes that his body is found soon and that the murderer is captured. Meanwhile, Black has returned to Istanbul after 12 years away. Before he left, Black fell in love with his cousin ...

  23. My Name Is Red Kindle Edition

    My Name is Red is a meditation on authenticity and originality . . . An ambitious work on so many levels at once."--Melvin Jules Bukiet, Chicago Tribune "Most enchanting . . . Playful, intellectually challenging, with an engaging love story and a full canvas of memorable characters, My Name is Red is a novel many, many people will enjoy."

  24. WTOP Book Report: In 'My Name Was Eden' one twin vanished in the womb

    In her riveting debut novel, My Name Was Eden (HarperCollins), UK-based author Eleanor Barker-White channels the profundity of life into art by telling the tale of a mother named Lucy, and her ...

  25. Skydance Sweetens Offer For Paramount

    Skydance's last offer included a sweetened $3 billion cash injection — up by at least $1 billion contemplated previously. What's key as a priority is Paramount holding enough cash on its ...

  26. What's new on Hulu in June 2024 and what's leaving soon

    Hulu's June 2024 lineup includes The Bear season 3, Clipped, The Batman, Joker, Shoresy season 3, Bullet Train, Fight Club, and more.The Latest Tech News, Delivered to Your Inbox.

  27. Caleb Carr, Author of Dark Histories, Dies at 68

    May 24, 2024. Caleb Carr, a military historian and author whose experience of childhood abuse drove him to explore the roots of violence — most famously in his 1994 best seller, "The Alienist ...